2 ms·
When somebody gives you tips on getting free food from restaurants, or saving money on your taxes, detecting whether someone has tampered with your computer, or
by pessimizer 13y ago
When somebody gives you tips on getting free food from restaurants, or saving money on your taxes, detecting whether someone has tampered with your computer, or X - arguing that you can't "trust that this is an absolute guarantee" of X is always going to be a strawman argument.
You should save those arguments for people who actually claim that you can trust that their method Y is an absolute guarantee of X. Hint: the words "absolute" and "guarantee" will be in the post.
edit: the only occurrence of "absolute" in the article:
>Short of keeping a machine with you 24/7, there is little you can do to be absolutely sure these things don’t happen[....]
- sillysaurus2 13y agoAh. Makes sense, thank you. I'm sorry if I set up a strawman, and it's worrisome to think I'm doing this without realizing it. In order to not do that anymore, I'll need to figure out how my argument was a strawman. It seems like the only reason people are interested in this is because they're believing it provides some sort of security; else it wouldn't be interesting by definition. So it seemed reasonable in turn to point out that this method isn't reliable. I suppose that's literally the definition of a strawman (they never claimed it was absolutely reliable) but I'm trying to understand why it was bad to infer people would see this as a protection mechanism rather than a detection mechanism. I'll be careful about this sort of thing in the future though.