3 ms·
Yes, the campaign is childish, but so are the article's misrepresentations. For example: (1) Google Docs - not Drive - does not have "nearly the same capabili
by notacoward 13y ago
Yes, the campaign is childish, but so are the article's misrepresentations. For example:
(1) Google Docs - not Drive - does not have "nearly the same capabilities" as Office by any reasonable definition. FFS, they don't even seem to have proper support for custom paragraph styles, widow/orphan control, etc. There are certainly ways in which Google Docs improves over Office, especially wrt collaborative editing, but there are also massive gaps that make it almost unusable for anything medium-size or larger.
(2) Microsoft's characterization of Chromebooks as "useless without the internet" is not entirely wrong. Constant internet connectivity might be the norm everywhere the author has gone, but it's still not something one can rely on in every corner of the globe. That being the case, "suitable for use while traveling" really might not apply sometimes. By the author's own cited definition, Chromebooks - like the one I'm typing this on - might not be real laptops for many people.
In both cases, the author starts with a grain of truth and then destroys his own point with exaggeration. The piece would have been far more effective if he had stuck with the facts - which are damning enough - instead of letting his bias shine through.
- anologwintermut 13y agoNot to mention, a lot of marketing is childish. The Mac vs. PC ads were childish. They worked ( to the extent anyone can say TV ads work)
- sigsergv 13y agoMac vs. PC campaign was also very ironic and inspiring (probably because it suggests and proposes new features, new way of thinking), but MSFT campaign is really stupid (if not worse, because it's merely portrays google in a negative light).
- Metrop0218 13y ago"especially wrt collaborative editing" - The office web apps got real time collaborative editing a couple of months ago [1]. I've used it and it works quite well. [1] http://blogs.office.com/b/office365tech/archive/2013/11/06/collaboration-just-got-easier-real-time-co-authoring-now-available-in-microsoft-office-web-apps.aspx http://blogs.office.com/b/office365tech/archive/2013/11/06/c...
- notacoward 13y agoThat's good to know, thanks. I haven't used it myself. I have used the collaborative editing in Google Docs, and it's done well enough that I don't see a whole lot of room for improvement, but I certainly wouldn't deny the possibility that Office has reached parity in this area.