4 ms·
This might be true... but if all they are trying to do is bomb the plane, what makes a plane bomb that much worse than, say, a bus bomb? You can ride greyhound
by cortesoft 13y ago
This might be true... but if all they are trying to do is bomb the plane, what makes a plane bomb that much worse than, say, a bus bomb? You can ride greyhound without going through rigorous screening, and yet no one has planted a bomb on a bus.
The excuse for the airplane security has been that they can use the plane as a missile. If this is no longer the case, than planes lose their special status as something that needs to be extra protected. If we feel safe getting on a bus without going through a metal detector, a plane should be no different.
Yes, people can do us harm at any time. They could shoot us, bomb us, stab us, burn us with acid, etc. We accept those risks every day, and almost all of us get through life without those things happening to us. That is because the number of people who want to do bad things to us isn't nearly as great as some would have us believe. We don't need more screening to protect us from very unlikely threats.
- jacalata 13y agoWell, they can still shower shrapnel over a large area and crash into the ground, right? I'm not really sure what kind of bomb would actually explode a plane, or what kind of damage it could do on the ground as an undirected crash landing/explosion.
- bunderbunder 13y ago> no one has planted a bomb on a bus What about the one that happened yesterday? http://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/killed-blast-station-russias-south-21359943 http://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/killed-blast-s...
- vxNsr 13y agoOff topic but: This is what happens when you support a volatile and people (terrorists) they come back and bite you too.
- cortesoft 13y agoOk, I was clearly wrong about no one bombing a bus. However, my main point is still true; there are countless places where there are lots of people in confined spaces that are vulnerable to a bomb. We are always vulnerable to harm from someone who wants to hurt us, and there is very little we can do to make us invulnerable to random violence. Thankfully, the risk of dying from random violence is extremely low, near the bottom of the list of things that can kill us. We waste a lot of resources and time trying to prevent someone from harming us on an airplane when it is no more or less vulnerable than anywhere else.
- bunderbunder 13y agoFair enough. But factual issues aside, stating that nobody attacks ground-based transit systems weakens that point rather than strengthening it. If you want to argue that near-complete security is infeasible, you're probably better served by acknowledging that attacks on something as pervasive and porous as a bus system are a real possibility. So that's why I thought it was necessary to challenge you on that point.
- avn2109 13y agoIt's worth noting that neither I nor anyone I know has heard of this bus bombing/mentioned it in conversation, and it's not on TV/frontpage of NYT, etc. But if we switch $Bus for $Plane, this becomes a major media event and everyone will know about it. What is it about aircraft that get the man and his propaganda machine so excited?
- johnpowell 13y agoFive years ago I took a Greyhound from Portland to Eugene. They looked through my bag when boarding. I also reeked of booze and the security guy suggested I get some mints and try again. But they were checking everyone.