4 ms·
You're engaging in the same question begging as the scientists in the linked piece. If we accept for the sake of argument that manned moon missions further the
by bradleyjg 13y ago
You're engaging in the same question begging as the scientists in the linked piece. If we accept for the sake of argument that manned moon missions further the cause of manned Mars missions, that still leaves us without a justification for manned Mars missions.
Manned Mars missions aren't any more "productive" than manned Moon missions. Both are terribly inefficient from any scientific or commercial perspective.
- logfromblammo 13y agoThere is no commercial perspective that does not include humans somewhere. The economy IS humans. Manned missions to other planets are exciting. Robot missions to anywhere are slightly more emotionally engaging than watching your Roomba sweep your kitchen floor. Star Trek succeeded as a television show because it had human actors telling a story, to the point that this fiction is more popular as an entertainment franchise than actual space exploration? Why? Actual space exploration has only produced a handful of biplanetary pedestrians, and only John Glenn has made any kind of a big deal about it. In my view, the end goal of space exploration is to transplant Earth-origin life to other planets--not just humans, but (at minimum) thousands of species. That goal is not served by ignoring the transporting-the-biologicals portion of space exploration. That means I am completely unwilling to fund with my dollars any scheme that allows other people to fritter away money on pure science that will never become applied science, specifically science applied to my personal lifestyle. Multiply me by the six billion people who will likewise never escape our gravity well, and you had darned well better start thinking about the politics and the economics along with the science. In short, I don't give a fig about whether it would make the boffins happier to do something else. Humans in space is what I am willing to pay for. If they don't want to play along with my non-optimal prejudices, I'd prefer that they be cut off from tax-derived funds entirely, and go with exclusively private funding. Ask for public money; act in the public's interest. The public is interested in seeing people in space. It IS stupid, and doesn't make sense. What else would make it a uniquely human endeavor?