5 ms·
Scientists Petition U.S. Congress for Return to the Moon
- fit2rule 13y agoThis is going to end up being a race to build the first helium-3 reactor on the moon, I just know it. After that happens - wow! We may well just enter the new Space Era after all. Trouble is, its also highly likely that it'll be the Chinese leading the way. If they didn't have such a violent history of human rights abuses as a nation, I'd be a little less concerned, but as it stands right now I can't see Chinese domination of space-based industry being a good thing. Then again, it might just solve the pollution problem if we can just push China up into space, and use clean technologies for deliveries back to us here on Earth. Here's hoping it happens within the next 50 years, anyway!
- rory096 13y agoDoesn't using the Moon's helium-3 presuppose that we're capable of creating energy-positive helium-3 reactions here on Earth? Though at the pace we're headed back to the Moon now, we're probably about on target to match the perennially thirty-year-off working fusion reactor.
- spiritplumber 13y agoWe just have to ask the hot space Nazis for technical assistance.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- fit2rule 13y ago>>Doesn't using the Moon's helium-3 presuppose that we're capable of creating energy-positive helium-3 reactions here on Earth? I think the only thing stopping us is the place to do it safely, and maybe the Chinese have realized that doing such things as he-3 experiments on the moon is probably not so difficult, after all .. I mean, of all the countries on Earth right now who would benefit from this sort of 'clean energy' production, it'd be the one place on Earth that humans have utterly shit on. So I'm all for it, by the way, even if it involves hot space Nazi's ..
- jerf 13y ago"Safely" is, if not outright trivial, at least a well-understood problem that is "easy" on the scale of energy generation problems. The problem is still commercial-scale net-positive fusion; I still haven't heard of anybody getting particularly close to that, with any known technology. (And I like to track the exotic ones, too.) There's less than no point to going to the moon to extract a fuel that we can't extract more energy than it took to collect.
- fit2rule 13y agos/he-3/something else then/ I highly doubt there is any reason to be on the Moon right now than preparation for total industrial exploitation. It may be that the Chinese space program is the only thing that will get China de-polluted.
- Retric 13y agoAbout 1 in 10,000th of earth bound helum is H3 which makes it several orders of magnitude cheaper to extract on earth than on the moon. PS: For scale the US reserve was over 1 billion kg of helium last I checked which works out to something like 100,000+kg of H3. At 20% effecency it takes ~260kg of H3 to run a 1GW power plant for 1 year. So, we might want to start mining H3 on the moon, but after getting 10+ H3 reactors running for 20+ years which is going to take a long time. However, I suspect where going to ignore designing H3 reactors for similar reasons as we are ignoring thorium basically the fuel is no the expensive part of nuclear reactors.
- fit2rule 13y agoSend robot to moon. Robot #1: locate he-3! he-3 robot finds he-3 on moon! Send 2 more robots to moon. Robot #2: build he-3 reactor! reactor robot starts to build reactor .. Robot #3: build little factory for making: robots! robot-building robot builds robot-building factory .. reactor robot is finished! Just Plug In! robot-building robot is finished! Plugged In! ROBOTS in SPACE!! (Edit: to answer this - "the fuel is not the expensive part of nuclear reactors", yes the most expensive part of all this is doing it on Earth.)
- bayesianhorse 13y agoIf it was this easy, there should already be robots building He-3 reactors on the moon. No, not from Earth. From other civilizations that built van Neumann drones millions or billions of years ago!
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- throwaway_yy2Di 13y agoThe obvious way to get He-3 is to synthesize it, by irradiating lithium with neutrons from a fission for fusion reactor. This is where commercial He-3 comes from today. Mining it on the moon is an idiotic attempt to rationalize its commercial value. In fact: lunar thorium is 3-4 orders of magnitude more abundant than He-3 [0][1], so if you wanted helium-3 from the moon, it would almost certainly be cheaper to mine lunar thorium instead, and use lunar nuclear fission reactors to synthesize it! Which doesn't fit in anyone's stupid sci-fi fantasy. For what it's worth, [0] estimates the total amount of he-3 in lunar regolith, over the entire surface, as only 2.4 million tons -- barely a fossil fuel. [0] http://www.lpi.usra.edu/meetings/lpsc2007/pdf/2175.pdf http://www.lpi.usra.edu/meetings/lpsc2007/pdf/2175.pdf [1] http://www.nature.com/ngeo/journal/v4/n8/fig_tab/ngeo1225_F1.html http://www.nature.com/ngeo/journal/v4/n8/fig_tab/ngeo1225_F1...
- peter303 13y agoNeither party particularly likes funding NASA (save if they have them in their home district). The Dems prefer to expand social spending over government R&D. The Repubs thinks government funded R&D is a deficit-rasiing frill. Thats whty they both were quick to shut down the shuttle program.
- cshenoy 13y agoIt'll be interesting to see if and how those positions will change once other countries like China and India make major advances in space technologies and discoveries.
- dave_miller 13y ago"Congress: please return to the moon"
- nationcrafting 13y agoSeems a bit 20th century to ask Congress for money to do it, when people like Elon Musk have shown you can do pretty much anything NASA can do privately at a 10th of the cost.
- JumpCrisscross 13y ago>when people like Elon Musk have shown you can do pretty much anything NASA can do privately at a 10th of the cost SpaceX replicates NASA's orbital launch capability with efficiencies to spare. The redundancy does not, however, extend to deep space exploration, landers and rovers, and sundry scientific and technological endeavours with limited near-term profit potential.
- melling 13y agoYes, but the private business model seems to be the best way to get more money into the space program. Apple has almost $150 billion is cash, and they don't know what to do with it. Google, Microsoft, etc also have large cash surpluses. Now if we could have 3 or 4 companies, anywhere in the world, like SpaceX, then we'd have hundreds of billions of dollars in the space program. NASA's budget is less than $16.6 billion for 2014.
- rayiner 13y agoThe cost of Apollo was about ~$170 billion 2005 dollars (about $200 billion adjusting for inflation since then). That's not including Mercury and Gemini (i.e. all the R&D necessary to get from where Space X is now, to where NASA was right before Apollo). Okay, so Apple and Microsoft and Google probably could bankroll a modern Apollo program. But doing so would be corporate suicide. There is absolutely no way it would yield returns in any time frame that would be acceptable to shareholders. This isn't the web, where capital investments are small enough that investors don't need a monitization story. If companies are committing tens of billions of dollars, there needs to be a compelling story of how they're going to recoup that investment and make a profit. Space X had one: launch contracts for commercial and government satellites. There is no such monetization story for the moon.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- hobbes78 13y agoDefinitely scientists have an opinion far from unanimous, as Stephen Hawking finds the idea "Stupid. Robots would do a better job and be much cheaper because you don't have to bring them back." http://www.todayinsci.com/H/Hawking_Stephen/HawkingStephen-Quotations.htm http://www.todayinsci.com/H/Hawking_Stephen/HawkingStephen-Q...
- bradleyjg 13y agoIf you look at the justification it is totally circular -- "we need to send people to the moon to learn how to send people to Mars". Much much more science can be done for the same price if you omit the humans. The commercial viability threshold is much much lower if you omit the humans. The one and only reason to send humans up to space in the foreseeable future is patriotic chest thumping. Well that and to stroke the adolescent fantasies of those who grew up on science fiction.
- tomkin 13y agoWhen you omit the humans, you omit the humanity of spaceflight. Neil deGrasse Tyson sums it up best: Tyson, an astrophysicist and director of New York City's Hayden Planetarium, agreed with his interviewer in saying that "the manned program is a force of nature on the educational pipeline of America. It is the force that excites people to want to become scientists in the first place." [1] Plus: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hi636wl6a1w http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hi636wl6a1w [1] http://www.space.com/8184-robots-humans-space-colbert-tyson-speak.html http://www.space.com/8184-robots-humans-space-colbert-tyson-...
- greeneggs 13y agoThat sounds like empty rhetoric to me. Is there actually any evidence for the manned space program being "the force that excites people to want to become scientists in the first place"? I am skeptical. Even if true, there are likely far more cost-effective ways of generating the same interest, either with robots or other educational programs. I don't see why a robotic program can't be inspirational. And anyway we don't have any shortage of scientists right now.
- squozzer 13y agoBeen there, done that. It might be worthwhile to use Earth-to-Moon travel as a benchmark -- such as we used "crossing the Atlantic" or "New York to LA". Otherwise, what's the use? 1) I suppose we could build factories to make stuff too dangerous or difficult to make on Earth. But LEO would probably work just as well more cheaply. 2) Build a "Super Guantanamo" where "life without parole" has some real teeth. We might find LEO, Sealabs, and near-Earth asteroids more useful. Going to Mars would be more difficult and more imaginative.
- maaku 13y agoSo once Lindberg crossed the atlantic, that was it? Been there, done that, no need to ever make a nonstop flight across the atlantic again?
- eudox 13y agoRobert Zubrin has spent a large chunk of his career[1] arguing that going to the Moon is absolutely worthless. Go to Mars instead, it's not orders of magnitude harder. Why the Moon? There is nothing of value. Some ice embedded in rock, extremely diluted He-3. Really, it's just useful as a megascale solar panel. [1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mm34Muv6Lsg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mm34Muv6Lsg is a good summary.
- Anon84 13y agoI'm a scientist (although not currently living in the US) and I definitely think we (the US in particular and humanity in general) should go back to the Moon and eventually Mars. Yes, we can (probably) do more science and for cheaper with robots. Yes, we can (probably) develop the same technologies we would other wise by focusing just on automated exploration but there is one very important thing only human exploration can do: Inspire generations of future scientists Never underestimate the power of seeing someone personally going where no one has ever gone before or doing something that has never been done before. Thousands of people cross the straight between England and France everyday, but when someone swims across it makes the news. Thousands of people skydive everyday, but when Felix Baumgartner jumped from higher and faster than anybody before it made the news. How many of the older generation of scientists and engineers chose (at least initially) that carrer path because they grew up watching Neil Armstrong bounce around on the Moon? Or watching the now defunct Space Shuttle take people to the edge of space and dreamt of doing the same? A big project similar to the space race could make science and engineering sexy again, and would have one other advantage that only giant projects with clearly defined goals have: It focuses research in one direction, speeding up technological evolution The reason why a bunch of nerds in the middle of the New Mexico desert were able to build an atom bomb in practically record time was because everyone had a clear idea of what the goal was and it was immediately clear when progress was being made towards it and when it was achieved. The same thing applies to the Space Race. When Kennedy first said "we choose to go the moon in this decade" it was far from clear that it would even be possible. But it gave everyone a clear and inspiring goal to strive for. "We choose to send a bunch of circuits to the moon" wouldn't have nearly the same effect. This is the reason we now talk of "moonshot projects" (and google has a whole division for them). They are almost impossible but the goal is sufficiently clear and inspiring to make people work hard until they are accomplished. Imagine what would be possible if Obama were to say "we choose to go to Mars before the end of the decade" and actually provided NASA and private contractors with the funds to do it? What technologies wouldn't be developed and commercialized that we haven't even dreamt of?
- tesseractive 13y agoSuppose we set a goal to build a dirigible the size of a small town that could float up in the air and people could live on it and it would have an expected lifespan of at least 30 years? It would be enormously expensive and I have little doubt that some new technologies would have to be pioneered to produce something so audacious. But at the end of the day, it's still reasonable to ask why that's a goal we should spend so much to achieve, and the fact that we would invent a bunch of cool technology along the way seems insufficient as a response. There are lots and lots of things that we could spend tons of money on that would produce a bunch of spin-off technology -- how would we decide which of these things we should dump truckloads of money into, and which ones we shouldn't?