5 ms·
Wouldn’t it be better if IANA or the regional Internet registries directly rented out the IP addresses to the ISP:s/companies who need them? Why let a middle-ma
by cpach 13y ago
Wouldn’t it be better if IANA or the regional Internet registries directly rented out the IP addresses to the ISP:s/companies who need them? Why let a middle-man collect the profits?
- wilhil 13y agoAwkward to say... These companies (at least RIPE) are non profit making - you join for a fixed fee and then you get as many IPs as you need. It would be a good idea on one hand and a pain on the other... I am trying to think of a counter to it in my head, but, I can't really... a small fee is easily absorbed in per user costs and so many companies use public ips for internal routing when a private ip would do a good job... Then again, you could get big companies asking to rent out more than they need and refusing to hand back... Even if there was fool proof way of provisioning and managing, I personally think it is far too late to do it :(
- bradleyjg 13y agoYes. Best would be a formula that increased the per ip cost the more ips you had. That would have at least two advantages: first it would pressure the legacy class A holders who are collectively sitting on 100M+ not publicly used addresses; second it would make it unprofitable to hoard and resell. The current method resembles water law in the US western states, which is just about the worst possible way to allocate access to a limited resource.
- noselasd 13y agoBit to late for that, and the people that already got the IP addresses are unlikely to give them back. The internet is basically the sum of all the BGP routes sitting around on routers, it's unlikely any single organization could have much success trying to reclaim and redistribute those addresses.