3 ms·
I don't buy this at all. Upward mobility never existed in the romanticized fashion that people like to talk about. There was never a point in time where billio
by wyager 13y ago
I don't buy this at all.
Upward mobility never existed in the romanticized fashion that people like to talk about. There was never a point in time where billionaires sprang out of the ground like dandelions. The most "mobile" periods in history were when vast stores of untapped wealth were first being tapped. Westward expansion, the gold rush, etc. That's obviously not going to be 100% of the time.
Today, I guess the closest thing is the internet. And a lot of people have gone rags-to-riches (or the more realistic not-riches-to-riches) through the internet. Maybe it's less mobility than, say, a hundred years ago, maybe not.
But really, that's beside the point. Every single person in the entire world has been "moving up" for the last 300 years. Things are constantly getting better. Even if we completely disregard the social progress that's been made (think abolition of slavery), the rapid progression of technology is constantly raising everyone's standard of living.
- vacri 13y agoUpward mobility is not "people become [m|b]illionaires". It's climbing up the social scale. Going from lower-middle-class to upper-middle-class is significant and a sign of upward mobility. Mostly though, it's about getting out of poverty and into the middle classes.
- sejje 13y agoSerious question: Doesn't that just define a new lower class? If everyone moves up to the middle-class, isn't that the new lowest class? Wouldn't the upper middle class from 50 years ago be pretty happy as lower middle class today? (I believe so) If so, doesn't that signify some solid progress?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoYes. This is why using relative measures of class are flawed.
- mijustin 13y ago"Every single person" in the world has not been moving up. ;) In the USA, there's a lot of data that says both absolute & relative mobility is getting worse: > The income of a typical working-age family grew considerably in the late 1990s. Around 2000, it stopped growing. In 2007, it started falling. and > An under-rated source of income growth for the middle class in the last 30 years, in face of slow-growing hourly wages, has been increased hours and the rise of dual-earner households, where the mother and father supplement each others' income. As a result, household income might actually understate* the middle-class crisis by counting the rising participation of women.* Source: http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/12/a-giant-statistical-round-up-of-the-income-inequality-crisis-in-16-charts/266074/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/12/a-giant-... Because "absolute mobility" uses household income as a barometer, it appears on the surface that households are doing better. But we've actually added a lot of dual-income earning families since 1950, which skews those stats. In reality: > The typical family with a stay-at-home wife/mom has seen incomes grow only 1 percent, after inflation, since 1980. > The good news here is that women have the degrees, the means, and the freedom to work when they want to. The bad news is that the Typical American Family has only seen rising incomes in the last half century because of working wives. Source: http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/10/how-americas-marriage-crisis-makes-income-inequality-so-much-worse/280056/?utm_content=buffera55d7&utm_source=buffer http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/10/how-amer...
- sejje 13y agoHe meant moving up in quality of life, not social status. It wasn't even implied, he said so rather specifically ("but really, that's beside the point.") I'd much rather be lower class today than upper class in 1776. Comfort, medicine, availability of safe food, etc is all far better now for all classes than it was then for the upper class. There's a big disparity, in some sense, between lower and upper classes in today's world, but the disparity doesn't show up in happiness or longevity so far as I know. Mostly it's about having nice things, or just wealth in general.
- MaysonL 13y agoThere's a big disparity, in some sense, between lower and upper classes in today's world, but the disparity doesn't show up in happiness or longevity so far as I know. Actually it does: poor people are not as happy as well-off people, on average. Also, for the past 30 or so years, US life expectancy for higher income workers has gone up substantially more then for lower income workers. See [1] for example, or search on "life expectancy by income level" [1] http://www.minnpost.com/second-opinion/2013/03/income-gap-plays-out-us-life-expectancy http://www.minnpost.com/second-opinion/2013/03/income-gap-pl...