3 ms·
3. Rule that the plaintiff lacks standing to sue because the only evidence that the plaintiff has that they have been a target of this law is a result of whistl
by pessimizer 13y ago
3. Rule that the plaintiff lacks standing to sue because the only evidence that the plaintiff has that they have been a target of this law is a result of whistleblowing, and if the evidence of a whistleblower, although both true and confirmed by the defendant, is accepted, this would encourage more whistleblowing, which is the worst possible outcome imaginable. Instead, the only parties who have standing are the ones who had been directly and secretly served with the order (to monitor all of the plaintiff's communications), and those parties only have standing to secretly challenge the order in a secret court.
You could rule that, too.
- CurtMonash 13y agoWell, standing is usually a matter of law. But yes, I was oversimplifying, and anyhow IANAL.
- pessimizer 13y agoMy point was that your oversimplification was deceptive. You state that the judge only has two choices, and it's a matter of record that the actual judge in question chose neither of them. >Well, standing is usually a matter of law. The constitutionality of the concept of standing was not in question.