3 ms·
I am an on again off again fan of Krugman in some respects. In this case he has managed to clarify the discussion, which is good! The truth is that bitcoins de
by EGreg 13y ago
I am an on again off again fan of Krugman in some respects. In this case he has managed to clarify the discussion, which is good!
The truth is that bitcoins derive most of their value from being a great medium of exchange and enabling things (smart contracts are ahead) that otherwise wouldn't be possible. Things like making no recourse payments online for the first time ever.
Bank of America did an analysis on the value of bitcoin and concluded that one of the components is the payment network. If PayPal's market cap is billions, why not bitcoin?
So I see this as giving a "floor" to the value of bitcoin via demand the same way as the US government's demand for dollars from its citizens (or the controversial petrodllar warfare theory and other shenanigans) boosts demand for the dollar. There is definitely a lot of demand boost in that.
And for now there is alsothe speculative bubbl. I don't know what the value of bitcoins should be, but it's certainly not zero - there will be demand for it by chinese millionaires trying to get their $ out of the country and bypass currency controls, and other things like that. And if the market cap is high enough, moving a few million dollars in bitcoins at a time won't move the market. Demand drives the price up.
- XorNot 13y agoIf you couldn't turn Bitcoins into USD, would you accept them as payment for something? That's your floor price. It's 0.
- EGreg 13y agoYes, if I can trade them for something else I need. Cashing out is a hassle anyway. It's true that dollars are more liquid. Does that mean you wouldn't accept a ton of free stuff if you couldny trade it for dollars but only other services?
- XorNot 13y agoThen why am I getting it for free? That's the point - it's not free. You don't need a currency for "free". You need a currency for things which have value.