4 ms·
Eliminating racial and gender discrimination
I think personalized DNA sequencing is the way to go. When applying for a job, include your DNA sequence as part of the application.
You could take this even further by providing real-time DNA comparisons (at least on genes that you care about) with people who are nearby. Such analysis could give you some guidance as to whether you should start a conversation with a stranger say.
- inklesspen 19y agoYeah, that's a great idea. Nobody's gonna stare at the hot chick's boobs when they've got her DNA on file! Totally scalable idea, amichall. Well, maybe in your world it is. See, in the real world, people don't give a crap about your dna. What matters is that you are a lazy black or a slut or whatever other stereotype they want to put on you. Profiling on DNA would just give another thing to discriminate against. Go watch Gattaca sometime, kthx.
- amichail 19y agoDiscrimination is a form of probabilistic reasoning in the presence of incomplete knowledge. Provide more information about the individual and discrimination will go away eventually. Companies aim to maximize their profits and it is in their best interest to hire the best people.
- inklesspen 19y agoCompanies aim to do many things, because they are a gestalt entity. In many companies, the higher-ups aim to perpetuate an 'old-boy' network, rewarding their friends with high-paying cushy jobs. They are actually aiming to discriminate, amichall. In addition, nobody is going to sit down, go through someone's DNA sequence, and say "oh, now I have more knowledge about John Freeman. I am going to discard my prejudices against black people because I have a sequence of letters in front of me! Rational thought is so great!" No, you eliminate discrimination through education and confrontation. Each generation that mixes with other groups will discriminate less than the one that came before. In conclusion, you, sir, are either severely misinformed about the world or an idiot. Or both.
- amichail 19y agoIf hiring the best people means the difference between your company succeeding or failing, then maybe you will put aside your prejudices and hire the best candidate for a job. As for going through a DNA sequence, obviously you would have software to look for patterns that are beneficial to your company. The check would be automated and quick. And please, no need for ad hominem attacks.
- inklesspen 19y agoThat's not an ad hominem attack. I wasn't saying your argument is wrong because you don't know how the world works. I was saying your argument is wrong because of X, Y, and Z, and incidentally you don't know how the world works. Your responses continue to show that you don't know how the world works. You aren't going to find DNA patterns that are beneficial to your company. Identical twins with identical DNA can have incredibly different personalities. Humans share 94% of our DNA with chimpanzees, amichall. In conclusion, please go watch Gattaca and then go join the real world for a bit.
- amichail 19y agoWell, I'm certainly not going to insult you, whether it's part of my argument or not. I may not reply to your future comments though.
- pg 19y agoThat's not an ad hominem attack. Technically, perhaps, but it was name-calling. I'd appreciate it if you wouldn't do that.
- brlewis 19y agoYou have to get extremely technical to claim that "either severely misinformed about the world or an idiot" is not an ad-hominem attack. Perhaps a compiler could not prove that the ad-hominem is reachable, but all us humans see it.
- cstejerean 19y agoWatch Gattaca to see this idea in action.
- aston 19y agoNobody's pointing out the fallacy that DNA is just the start of how a person actually is? Even if there were genes that were easily identifiable for beauty, personality, intelligence, leadership or anything else you cared about, there's no guarantee that potential would have been fulfilled.
- amichail 19y agoOf course, effort is required as well. But at least you can use this approach to prune out candidates where that potential is lacking.