3 ms·
My view is that infinitesimals were a mistake, a long, festering sore in math and some of its applications. Can think intuitively about infinitesimals if you wa
by graycat 13y ago
My view is that infinitesimals
were a mistake, a long, festering
sore in math and some of its applications.
Can think intuitively about infinitesimals
if you want, but I see no need to
mess up the now very clean situation
on the foundations of the reals.
Indeed, as a grad student, I had some
results and went to see a world famous
prof to show him what I had and ask
him if my work seemed new to him.
At one point he suggested an improvement,
and, curiously, as a high end pure
mathematician in analysis
did his first cut, intuitive reasoning
in terms of infinitesimals! Fine.
But Dedekind cuts, Cauchy sequences,
etc. make a rock solid foundation for the
reals, and now can we just get on with,
say, Fourier theory and the rest of
analysis and their applications?