4 ms·
Funny, I ran a similar comparison and came up with ~$9000 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6937203 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6937203 I didn't in
by bane 13y ago
Funny, I ran a similar comparison and came up with ~$9000 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6937203 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6937203
I didn't include ECC RAM which might up the price a bit. My conclusion was that there really wasn't much of an Apple tax anymore.
However, I think the system is spec'd wrong. In same ways it's spec'd out like a server, in others like a high-end CAD workstation...but it's not really suitable for the former and the market for the latter is really small.
As a server the overly expensive video is completely unnecessary. And the form factor is all wrong anyways.
For gaming, music production, video editing, photo work, etc. the workstation-class video parts, CPU and expensive RAM aren't useful and the storage is too small anyways.
Nobody targeting either class of user would spec a system out like this.
So who is this targeted at? The more stationary rMBP users who do lots of virtualization and want more RAM with the occasional CAD work and/or bitcoin mining?
I dunno, this product line feels weird.
I just built a pretty decent system that I'm expecting to last for the next 4-5 years and spent well under $2k.
Core i7-4770K
Nvidia GTX680
32GB RAM
512GB SSD
4TB HD
Blue Ray writer
+ some other odds and ends and they tossed in 3 free brand new games.
However, I would have liked to have it running with fewer fans, in a smaller case (half the size of my current mid-tower would have been nice).
Had I gone with 2x the RAM and a pair of the top of the line video card I would have still been around the cost of the lowest end Mac Pro at better day-to-day performance. But then again, my case is huge compared to this thing. Hell, I think my CPU cooling setup alone is about the same size as a Mac Pro.
I think the good thing is that at least the small size and high power at least has the tech world thinking and talking again, about part sizes and shapes, airflow, heat management etc. I predict some fast followers in the PC market at various specs and similarly sized form factors, including the huge open gap in the Apple lineup.
Maybe my next system build in 5 years will be in a tube shaped case with a single fan and much smaller parts?