3 ms·
Lets be realistic about how the "rape sufferers" incident happened. They started with some list of standard medical conditions joined against users: condit
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Lets be realistic about how the "rape sufferers" incident happened. They started with some list of standard medical conditions joined against users:
condition user
dermatititis 1
rape 2
athletes foot 3
Then they did this:
SELECT UNIQUE(condition) FROM user_sufferers
<h1> Lists for sale </h1>
{% for condition in conditions %}
<li> {{condition}} sufferers </li>
{% endfor %}
Fundamentally no different from
["Keep Calm and {{verb}} a Lot" t-shirts for verb in list_of_verbs]:
http://singularityhub.com/2013/03/20/keep-calm-and-rape-a-lot-t-shirts-show-automation-growing-pains/ http://singularityhub.com/2013/03/20/keep-calm-and-rape-a-lo...
The fact that things like rape, pregnancy [1], etc are detectible by computers makes great headlines. But we shouldn't act as if MedBase was deliberately targeting [{{condition}} sufferers for condition in hot_button_list] - that's fundamentally dishonest.
[1] See the case when Target knew some teenager was interested in products X, Y, Z, where the correlation was driven by the underlying causation of pregnancy.
- mortov 13y agoAre you saying you know this for a fact or are you speculating a benign explanation without any genuine knowledge of this particular case (by referring to the keep calm t-shirts which are unrelated and irrelevant to this situation) ? edit: Plus I've never heard of "rape" being a diagnosed medical condition - why would that be in a list of conditions ? I find your 'explanation' quite troubling.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI'm saying this is the most likely explanation. I should have been more clear on this point. Too late to edit, unfortunately. Incidentally, here is a cached list of the things they sell (the site is now not displaying them): http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:dI3aEj0xkSIJ:www.medbase200.com/ailmentslists.php%3Fpage%3D1%26ipp%3DAll+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:dI3aEj0... http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:8T2YX7hPZcwJ:www.medbase200.com/prescriptiondruguserlists.php%3Fpage%3D56%26ipp%3D10+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:8T2YX7h... http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:aRARHlll5K8J:www.medbase200.com/ailmentslists.php%3Fpage%3D66%26ipp%3D10+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:aRARHll... I stand by my claim that they took a list of medical billing codes or something like that. Really, you think a human decided to compile a list of "Bioterrorism sufferers", "Smallpox sufferers", "Bites and Stings sufferers" or "Polio Sufferers"? However, I'm now convinced their first step was less sophisticated than I suggested. I think they didn't take a list of users joined against billing codes, I think they just took a list of billing codes.
- louthy 13y ago> edit: Plus I've never heard of "rape" being a diagnosed medical condition - why would that be in a list of conditions ? I find your 'explanation' quite troubling The SNOMED CT coding system has an incredible number of coded clinical terms. Including rape: http://phinvads.cdc.gov/vads/http:/phinvads.cdc.gov/vads/ViewCodeSystemConcept.action?oid=2.16.840.1.113883.6.96&code=54231004 http://phinvads.cdc.gov/vads/http:/phinvads.cdc.gov/vads/Vie...
- mortov 13y agoThe condition it lists in your example is "Rape trauma syndrome" - that would be an acceptable medical diagnosis as it is the trauma associated with being raped (and medical support and intervention could be necessary to deal with this). The rape itself is not a medical condition, and I think that definition listed makes that clear. I still would not like the idea of a list of rape trauma victims being sold as that almost by definition would add to the trauma they have suffered if they knew this happened.
- louthy 13y agoSorry, I should have dug a bit deeper for the exact code. SNOMED CT covers non-clinical terms along with clinical ones. It covers tons and tons of 'stuff' from measurements, drugs, finding areas, diagnoses, substances, social contexts, foods, etc. The point was to create a coding system which captured more than just clinical information. SNOMED CT is used to build 'clinical statements' which are combinations of SNOMED CT-terms to help build a more in-depth patient record. Many of those terms are non-clinical, but can be used in combination with clinical-terms. Here's 'Victim of Statutory Rape': http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SNOMEDCT?p=classes&conceptid=http%3A%2F%2Fpurl.bioontology.org%2Fontology%2FSNOMEDCT%2F17044007 http://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/SNOMEDCT?p=class... I run a company that develops a web-based medical practice management system. We use NLP techniques combined with the SNOMED CT database (and others) to extract clinical-statements from all text inputted against a medical record. Whether it's a complaint, treatment, diagnosis, or even an email to the patient. So I don't doubt for a second that there are other systems out there that do a similar thing and have auto-associated patients with various clinical and non-clinical terms.
- route66 13y agoSo, criticizing that a company collects and indexes sensitive medical data of individuals without insight in what the are producing and selling is "intellectually dishonest" when we single out the fact that they are selling rape victim data collections? Just explaining how things might have come to be, as you do in this strawman exercise, doesn't make it acceptable, or does it?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThe article attempts to imply that selling a list of "rape sufferers" was deliberate: The company pretended like the list was a huge mistake. A MEDbase rep tried convincing a Wall Street Journal reporter that its rape dossiers were just a “hypothetical list of health conditions/ailments.” Given the existence of "bioterrorism sufferers" and "polio sufferers" on the list, this explanation seems almost certain to be true. They stuck every medical condition on the list in order to boost their SEO, and they didn't realize that their list of conditions included hot button topics. If you want to argue that data brokering is unacceptable, do it honestly and without pretending they are selling lists of rape victims and lepers.