3 ms·
> Most apps are just buttons and pages and pictures and videos, and for that kind of stuff, I honestly don't see what the advantage of native is over HTML. Th
by Zigurd 13y ago
> Most apps are just buttons and pages and pictures and videos, and for that kind of stuff, I honestly don't see what the advantage of native is over HTML.
This is true for very simple apps. But native platforms have developed UI conventions that should be followed for non-trivial apps, and modularity capabilities that should be exploited. Taking Android as the example:
Fragment is the way Android apps scale between small and large displays, and how such apps are modularized.
ActionBar is how commands for fragments are added to "global" UI elements as the Fragment objects appear.
The Share action is how data is moved in the highest-level, user-directed way; Intent and startActivityForResult is how apps borrow UI and capabilities from each other; bound service RPCs is how apps can call each other's APIs. You can't do that with Web apps.
Android arguably has a more powerful feature set for modularity and inter-app cooperation that has been held back from achieving its potential fro users because too many apps started with a Web app or an iOS implementation. Android also has UI conventions that are sophisticated and good-looking and that users will increasingly value apps for adhering to.
- erikpukinskis 13y agoThanks for this! I haven't used Android in probably 3 years so I'm less aware of those things. On iOS the apps seem to be more self contained. The issue of conventions does seem to be the crux of it. They can be powerful, although sometimes people seem to rely on conventions because they can't be bothered to figure out an actual powerful, simple, learnable, comprehensible interface for their application. A lot of "non-trivial" apps could be made trivial through good design. In the absence of that, yes: if your users have to jump through hoops they better be the conventional hoops. So in that sense my point remains. But I have no idea what proportion of apps fall into the "could be designed down into something more intuitive" va "is inherently very complex and must rely heavily on conventions" categories. I should boot up my old Android with the new OS and familiarize myself with the new hotness. When I used it last the conventions like the back button and menus and such we're so randomly applied you couldn't really rely on them anyway.