2 ms·
The thing that amuses me about anarcho-capitalism is that the state seems vitally necessary for capitalism to work. Whoa horsey. You can drive a Mack truck thr
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
The thing that amuses me about anarcho-capitalism is that the state seems vitally necessary for capitalism to work.
Whoa horsey. You can drive a Mack truck through that over-generalization.
Some kind of collective enforcement of property rights and contract law might be required, but that's so far from a modern state it's not funny.
It's one thing for a European to shake down some rubes who didn't know enough be cautious and weren't part of his peer group. But we have lots of examples of property and contracts being respected where very, very little government exists. Venice merchants and the silk road, the western United States during the period between 1776 and 1787, Roman traders operating deep inside "primitive" lands, modern mafia bosses and their business deals, Ebay shoppers and reputation-supported transactions. I can go on -- at length.
There's such a little need for government that social mores seem to do just fine in most cases. If there is some role for government at all (and I think there is), it's nowhere near the intrusive monstrosity we have today. Just because the door is open a crack doesn't mean that a herd of elephants can run through. I think that anarcho-capitalism won't work, don't get me wrong. But the degree of community control required for business to flourish is very, very minimal. At least as far as I can see.
It's certainly not a big enough flaw to give up on libertarianism, at least with the little "l"
- philwelch 17y ago"You can drive a Mack truck through that over-generalization." Can you? Oddly enough, the only capitalisms we've seen in history are states, and the only anarchies we see are...well, places like Somalia. "Some kind of collective enforcement of property rights and contract law might be required, but that's so far from a modern state it's not funny." But it is, however, a state. Development economics shows us that institutions of some sort are necessary. None of the examples you gave were ultimately sustainable. At the least you'd need an authoritative record of who owns what--and with multiple private defense agencies each having their own record, there will be disagreements. Instead of property rights we'd have civil wars. But fundamentally, we agree--you're not an anarcho-capitalist. And I think we agree that a lot of what the government does is unhelpful. Still, registering property rights and having the power to enforce them is such a fundamental role it's easy to forget.