14 ms·
Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject
- webo 13y agoI really don't think teaching some basic syntax and some scripting is "computer science." It would help students a lot more if we started offering courses like discrete mathematics instead.
- Crito 13y agoAgreed. That sort of thing is to "computer science" as "shop class" is to "mechanical engineering". Mechanical engineering students generally take many shop classes, and computer science students spend a lot of their time learning vocation-styled computer skills. All are important, I could get behind getting more of any or all of these into highschools (though programming less so than the other three), but I don't think we should be honest with the terminology we use. If for nothing else, we should keep our terminology straight and honest so that we do not perpetuate misconceptions about what fields actually entail.
- my_username_is_ 13y agoEven if it isn't "true" CS, they're likely to learn useful skills that can help them automate repetitive tasks and things like that, and give them enough exposure to decide if it's something they may want to do in the future. If they decide to study it more in depth, awesome. If not, the worst that happens is they got a few skills that may help them in the future
- Crito 13y agoAye, it seems like a good enough idea.. I just think that they should be more accurate with what they call it. Inaccuracy does not do anybody any favours.
- wildgift 13y agoIt's K-12. They don't name anything quite right. Having some programming background is a good thing. In fact, I think it would be better if the courses were more broad than deep, and looked at things like programming graphics, programming robots, programming microcontrollers in appliances, the internet protocols, wireless networking, encryption, sequential circuits, logic gates, etc.
- sehr 13y agoI know HN is really, really focused on semantics. I know this. But seriously, every single time one of these articles pops up with the GP calling programming 'cs', the majority of the discussion is focused on calling out how it's incorrect. Now I may be wrong, but I know that I personally would much rather have been creating something with some basic syntax as opposed to learning theory while I was in grade school. Being able to see your seemingly magical incantations create something cool is going to be a lot more encouraging than studying discrete mathematics. Theory is cool. Theory has its place, but before you even encounter the situations in which it's applicable, I'd say try making something first. EDIT -- Especially when these kids are low income. Discrete mathematics to inner city kids is about as relatable as Biggie is to Wall Street bankers.
- frostmatthew 13y agoI agree it's probably better to teach children some basic syntax instead of discrete mathematics but I think part of webo's point was you can teach basic syntax without calling it "Computer Science"
- jamesbritt 13y agoEspecially when these kids are low income. Discrete mathematics to inner city kids is about as relatable as Biggie is to Wall Street bankers. Is this something recent? I went to grade school (long time ago) with low-income and inner-city kids and quite a few were intellectually curious and interested in abstract ideas.
- 13y ago
- jebus989 13y agoYeah and in so-called "English language" why are they teaching kids how to use semi-colons and paragraphs instead of etymology and James Joyce.
- timthorn 13y agoBecause James Joyce is taught in English Literature, not English Language.
- jebus989 13y agoA mind-numbingly tedious point, even for HN. Unsurprisingly English language courses also require study of written texts [0] but that's irrelevant for the purposes of the analogy. [0] http://www.aqa.org.uk/subjects/english/gcse/english-language-4705/subject-content http://www.aqa.org.uk/subjects/english/gcse/english-language...
- bonemachine 13y agoThe point I suspect is not to make them all into little Knuths. It's to make sure they have at least some exposure, so they can decide if this something they want to pursue in a focused way later on -- and, importantly, regardless of their parents' own professional background (or lack thereof). BTW, perhaps you're forgetting -- they're just 8th graders. We're luck of half of them can pass a pre-Algebra class. Any coding skills we can get them to learn on top of that is a huge, huge win.
- Nursie 13y agoIn the UK, kids do (or did) get taught various forms of discrete mathematics at fairly young ages. Boolean algebra, very basic set theory etc. However, to get some basic programming done, you don't really need any of this, and in fact the code may help you grasp some of the maths so it might even be better to start that first. Either way, the world runs on code now, it's everywhere. Giving all children a small taste of that, so that they can decide later if they want to pursue it as an interest or a career, is a good thing.
- vezzy-fnord 13y agoSo, is it computer science or computer programming? This is only going to add a truckload of fuel to the already huge fire that is the confusion between computer science and computer programming. But to be less pedantic, let's actually focus on what this will entail. First of all, "learning to code" is as ambiguous as "learning a [natural] language". Not all natural languages are Latin, and not all programming languages are ALGOL. Second, I am highly skeptical as to the intentions of this movement. Yet criticizing it is bound to get you labeled a cynic, a Luddite, an obscurantist or a combination of those. After all, teaching kids to code? How benevolent of them! Not when you realize that the big moguls standing behind this are probably more concerned about having typists who can write instructions, rather than skilled programmers and computer scientists. I'm not saying this out of spite, but because of how they've presented their agenda (I'm referring to Code.org, primarily). The sugar coating, the testimonials from everybody besides actual computer scientists and their setting of sex quotas and affirmative action to create the illusion of desiring equality. Notice how they all focus on the code. They rarely even use the word "programming". This should already set off an alarm. As the proprietary software giants are standing by this, they are very likely to focus on proprietary platforms. They don't talk about this, of course. It's all about the code. About imagination, creativity and dreams. Have fun fulfilling your dreams on a locked down tablet with a TPM chip. The issue of software freedom, I believe, is more important than bashing instructions, which is a skill anyone can pick up, if they so desire. But there will be none of that. How many of these kids will be taught about GNU? I'm assuming none. But I'm sure there's going to be lots of Visual Studio and C#, plus iOS and Objective-C. Ultimately, this will either drive away children from programming (depending on how it's taught, but let's face it: compulsory schooling is notorious for just how apt it is at sucking the life and fun out of learning... even more when Code.org is pushing for pay deductions on teachers whose CS classrooms consist of <40% females), or it will reduce the general quality of labor. Many will be uninterested, many will refine their skills, but many will become 9-to-5 enterprise monkeys as a direct result of this. I really want to support this. I do. But it really keeps looking like learning to code is just a facade. Of course, the children will learn something, but the ulterior agenda and how their perception will be skewed is something distressing.
- rayiner 13y ago
- StefanKarpinski 13y agoMy god, people. Why is there so much dickish nitpicking in this thread? This is great news! It is mind blowing (to me at least) that basic knowledge of programming is not a general requirement – and this is a step in the right direction, regardless of whether the terminology is exactly fucking correct or not.
- vezzy-fnord 13y agoIt's not dickish nitpicking, it's expressing genuine concerns. Language is meant to be used properly. "Basic knowledge of programming" doesn't actually mean anything.
- sehr 13y agoOf course language is meant to be used properly. But judging by the bastardization of other technical phrases, (e.g. hacker) and their criticism, these discussions will amount to nothing. And in taking part in these discussions, we're really only shouting into an echo chamber. I seriously doubt many non technical people browse hacker news.
- lemonberry 13y agoHow does "basic knowledge of programming" not mean anything? Almost every book on programming starts with "basics" section.
- StefanKarpinski 13y agoThere is no such thing as "proper usage of language". Language means what we all agree that it means which is a consensus that evolves over time. Unlike programming languages, it has no fixed or proper meaning or usage. I think that most of us can agree that while it may not be precise, "basic knowledge of programming" does actually mean something. It is distinct from, say, basic knowledge of French or basic knowledge of juggling – hence, it means something. And from the number of upvotes my original post is getting, it seems that at least a few people agree that some of the commentary in this discussion is, in fact, dickish nitpicking.
- gmichnikov 13y ago
- icegreentea 13y agoUgh, had to go scurrying around to find this info (really wish they linked it directly), but here's the actual proposal (and its press release): 1) In the next three years, every high school will offer a foundational “Exploring Computer Science” course. (This is a survey course - my note) 2) In the next five years, at least half of all high schools will also offer an AP Computer Science course. (My note: AP CS is a Java based course that looks roughly comparable to first year computer engineering courses, including algorithms and data structure... I've never taken AP CS, but I bet lots of people here have, and they can probably elaborate on its usefulness) 3) Chicago will also be the first US urban district to offer a K-8 computer science pathway, reaching one in four elementary schools in the next five years. 4) Within five years, CPS will allow computer science to count as a graduation requirement (e.g. possibly as a math, science, or foreign language credit). Only thirteen other states have elevated computer science to a core subject instead of an elective. http://www.cityofchicago.org/city/en/depts/mayor/press_room/press_releases/2013/december_2013/mayor-emanuel-and-cps-ceo-barbara-byrd-bennett-announce-comprehe.html http://www.cityofchicago.org/city/en/depts/mayor/press_room/... And for reference, here is CPS' current requirements for highscool graduation: http://www.cps.edu/SiteCollectionDocuments/PromotionPolicy/HSGraduationReq_English.pdf http://www.cps.edu/SiteCollectionDocuments/PromotionPolicy/H...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- StefanKarpinski 13y agoThank you for finding all of that. I think it squashes a lot of the negativity and objections elsewhere in this discussion. That is a legitimate sounding computer science curriculum and it's incredibly refreshing that it puts the discipline on a par with traditional fields.
- sillysaurus2 13y agoAnyone who's cheering this proposal should remember how well making mathematics compulsory has worked out for us. How many kids are (justifiably) disgusted with advanced mathematics because it's forced on them? It's also important to remember highschool teachers aren't college professors. You may have had awesome and passionate HS teachers, but from what I saw, there don't seem to be very many. I think the quickest way to destroy a future programmer is by forcing them to learn dumb ideas from half-interested teachers during their formative years, and it seems like this proposal will lead to that. It's hard to understand why people trust the modern highschool system to teach kids anything. Most of the kids aren't there to learn; they're there because they're forced to be. If an ambitious highschooler wants to learn programming, why not give them a way to learn it in a university early? I really hope I'm wrong, but in my experience the highschool system is a grim situation for nerds, especially in the Midwest. EDIT: Regarding highschool teachers vs CS professors: I meant that teaching programming requires programming ability, not just teaching ability. Maybe highschool teachers will become good programmers first. I don't know. And certainly, awful college professors exist just like awful highschool teachers exist. It just seems like the average CS professor has a higher chance of imparting useful knowledge to kids than a highschool teacher who has to learn it from the same book as the kids they're teaching it to. Worse, the kids have a high chance of becoming disgusted with the idea of programming if it's taught poorly, so this proposal seems at least as potentially dangerous as it is potentially helpful.
- tslathrow 13y agoUnrelated: Don't go to UChicago if you want to study CS. The department isn't built out. Consider UPenn SEAS or Columbia Fu for a similar tier CS program. It's really excellent for economics (which I was considering), but ended up not going to Chicago after talking to some of the comp sci majors.
- dcre 13y agoThat's not completely fair: the math department is world-class, and the computer science department is sort of an offshoot of it. It does have a very theoretical bent. That doesn't mean it's bad.
- sillysaurus2 13y agoHe didn't say it's bad, but rather that it's not built out. It's true that all else equal, UChicago isn't a good choice for CS. Anyone have thoughts about UIC? djb is a professor there, and it seems like their CS department is pretty extensive.
- onedev 13y agoAs well all know though, UIUC is where it's at for CS.
- selectodude 13y agoOf course, but I would say UIC is very good as well.
- davidmr 13y agoIt might not be what you were looking for, but to say it's not "built out" is a bit of a reach. I don't see how a department whose faculty include Alexander Razborov and Laszlo Babai can be considered lightweight. If you're interested in theory, UofC is a very good place to go. Are they upenn, columbia, cmu, etc.? No, but they're not trying to be. It's much more an extension of the Mathematics program than at many other places. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Razborov http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Razborov http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/László_Babai http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/László_Babai
- bane 13y agoSo right now is the time to start a long-term study on all of the students who go through the program to see if it prepares them better for CS/various engineering disciplines in higher-ed.
- spitfire 13y agoComputer Science or Programming? There's a wide gap between the sorts of problems you can solve (or even identify) with the two skill sets.
- yen223 13y agoHopefully the latter. There's no practical reason for a biologist to understand Djikstra's algorithm, but a lot of professions will benefit from being able to code up helper scripts.
- randomdata 13y agoPerhaps my view is blurred by being a programmer, but I have never found the skill to be particularly useful in my non-programming side businesses. It is a nice idea that biologists will write helper scripts, but my experience in the real world is more like: 1. Someone has already written the code, so there is no reason to write it again 2. The problem is big enough that you are going to end up spending all your time programming, taking time away from what you should really be working on And maybe there is a need for biologists working on new research where there are no existing tools that match what they are working on, but I don't think that is something that extends to a lot of professions.
- SonOfLilit 13y agoHi! I'm really interested in this, and all my anecdotal data (in the hundreds of points) points against what you're saying. I'd love to discuss your experience. I can also bring a few biologists into the discussion, to make it more interesting. Could you please email me at my nick on gmail?
- ffrryuu 13y agoThere goes the job market
- georgehaake 13y agoLipstick on a pig...
- IgorPartola 13y agoPardon the aside, but: "A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects." ~ Robert A Heinlein One of my favorite quotes. (Emphasis mine.)
- xname 13y agoWow. Read the comments make me wondering why so many geeks are so incapable of thinking social issues. Do you guys have even a little bit of sense of human feeling? How come this is a good news? If the news says Chicago students love computer science, it could be a good news. But it is not what the news said. Instead, the news is: all Chicago students will be Required to learn computer science. How can this be a good news? Will you consider requiring all students to join football team or to play piano a good news? Unbelievable ...
- frozenport 13y agoSchools will need to teach this instead of core performance indicators. Unlike reading, math, and science, there exists no relevant metric for measuring 'computer science' proficiency.
- wglb 13y agoI think there is a common confusion about the term Computer Science. Universities such as University of Chicago teach raw CS. UIUC and U. of Ill. teaches what I would call Computer (Software) Engineering. These courses are likely neither of the two, but more of the nature of "practical computer programming".
- sundresh 13y agoHaving studied CS at UIUC, the undergrad CS curriculum on the U Chicago website is indistinguishable from my own undergrad requirements. I would have to agree that the public school curriculum would be about the basics of how computer systems work and how to use them vocationally, rather than say proofs of computational complexity.
- nicolethenerd 13y agoI see several comments on this thread re: 'where are they going to get the teachers?' Not sure what Chicago is planning to do, but I'd love to see them follow the TEALS k-12 model (http://www.tealsk12.org/ http://www.tealsk12.org/) - TEALS is an organization that brings software engineers into high schools to teach computer science (so you, yes you, can teach CS!) - there is a regular classroom teacher in the classroom w/ you, and while they help you out w/ teaching/classroom management etc, you are helping them to learn about computer science - so after a few semesters of assisting in intro CS classes, these full-time teachers are prepared to teach it themselves. Awesome program. Also, notes on AP CS - a few years ago, the AP CS AB test (this is the one with all the data structures and stuff) was discontinued - currently the only AP CS class that exists is the AP CS A test (that is, the easier version, that covers a fraction of the material of the AB test). Also currently under development is "AP CS Principles" - an even softer, more humanities focused AP course that deals w/ the role of computers in society in addition to programming. I have mixed feelings about this - on one hand, it'll introduce way more kids to computer science and give them a degree of technical literacy that today's kids really ought to have... on the other hand, not sure how I feel about the 'dumbing down' of the curriculum - I loved CS AB - it was probably the best course I took in high school, and it's a shame that many students will no longer have that opportunity.
- etler 13y agoThat seems like a great program. I too am skeptical about their ability to find enough CS teachers that are qualified to teach, so I hope they have a plan other than giving random teachers a book and setting them on their own. If you haven't posted this to hacker news yet, you definitely should! They look like they need and deserve more attention.