3 ms·
I wonder if you don't get all the cross-references and cultural comments. When I spoke with another programmer who preferred HHGttG over Pratchett it rapidly b
by ColinWright 13y ago
I wonder if you don't get all the cross-references and cultural comments. When I spoke with another programmer who preferred HHGttG over Pratchett it rapidly became clear that he was looking for jokes, not realising that the vast majority of the humour is not in the jokes, but in the structure, language, ping-backs, and other re-interpretations of external material.
So, in short, maybe you just don't it. That's fair enough. Not everyone has the context in which to insert it.
My wife has just asked if you're reading Craig Shaw Gardner, whose covers are also done by Josh Kirby.
PS: I wish people wouldn't downvote just because someone has a different opinion, especially when it's just a personal preference.
- coldtea 13y ago>I wonder if you don't get all the cross-references and cultural comments. When I spoke with another programmer who preferred HHGttG over Pratchett it rapidly became clear that he was looking for jokes, not realising that the vast majority of the humour is not in the jokes, but in the structure, language, ping-backs, and other re-interpretations of external material. I doubt that's it. I'm a book freak and I've also consumed tons of music/TV/net, so I can get the cultural/cross references to external material in stuff ranging from Derrida to Woody Allen and the Family Guy. I've actually had this contest with a friend who insisted on Pratchett: we'd read together a tome until we found a good joke. I gave up after 50 or 60 pages, and he too was buffled that nothing seemed as good as he remembered it so as to justify it. >My wife has just asked if you're reading Craig Shaw Gardner, whose covers are also done by Josh Kirby. No, not really.
- ColinWright 13y ago>> My wife has just asked if you're reading >> Craig Shaw Gardner, whose covers are also >> done by Josh Kirby. > No, not really. Worth checking - it's a mistake one of our friends made. Anyway ... > ... we'd read together a tome until we found > a good joke. I wonder if this is the mis-match in your expectations. Yes, there are jokes in Pratchett, but that's not where the majority of the humour lies. It's more about word-play and visual imagery. It's not to everyone's taste, and I'm not trying to convert you, but given enough time it would be interesting to find where the difference is between us that makes me really, really enjoy most Pratchett (although not all), and for you, not. But there is no time, so it will remain a mystery.