3 ms·
I'm not convinced. I've gone back and re-read "The Colour of Magic" and found it to be significantly less entertaining than "Guards! Guards!" In fact, I found
by ColinWright 13y ago
I'm not convinced. I've gone back and re-read "The Colour of Magic" and found it to be significantly less entertaining than "Guards! Guards!" In fact, I found "The Colour of Magic" much better after having read the other stories.
A colleague of mine agrees with you, saying that TCoM was published on its own merit - others may have ridden the wave of success, but I say that the canon of work is there, why not pick a good place to start?
As a metaphor, you don't insist everyone learn ForTran, then BASIC, then Pascal, etc., before learning a modern language. You choose where to start.
<fx: shrug />
Start somewhere.
- mickeyp 13y agoThe first two are standalone, yes. They're also different in style to the rest as Pratchett had yet to find his voice for the series. However, they do introduce two very important characters that remain some of the most popular in the series. I would call that a false dichotomy, Colin. Most of the books are standalone, technically, yes; but consider this: most people who look at the reading order wouldn't know why they should read the witches novels nor the watch novels - so why not just start at the beginning and let it unfold as the author wrote them?