3 ms·
Why should race (or gender) matter? As a south-american, the term african-american irks me. It reeks of political correctness, not respect. http://en.wikipedia
by ricardobeat 13y ago
Why should race (or gender) matter?
As a south-american, the term african-american irks me. It reeks of political correctness, not respect. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euphemism_treadmill#Evolution http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euphemism_treadmill#Evolution
EDIT: eh, what did I get myself into... over here we're just plain white/black/latin/asian/etc, despite some media usage of the term 'afro-descendant'. I do support affirmative action policies in general, it's just my personal opinion that teaching kids to be self-conscious about race in this context is not necessarily positive.
- SwellJoe 13y agoBecause race still effects the world we live in. To insist on a "color blind" view of society, our industry, etc. is to deny the real experience of people of color within it, who have found discrimination and prejudice. We can and should say to racists that try to prove some sort of race-based superiority that genetically "race" is a silly fiction, and has no basis in reality. But, we can't deny that black folks in America have a very different experience than white folks. Doing so is counter-productive to the conversation that needs to happen.
- javert 13y ago> To insist on a "color blind" view of society, our industry, etc. is to deny the real experience of people of color within it, who have found discrimination and prejudice. I inisit on color blindness in all kinds of social, business, and political relationships, but I do not deny that blacks have a much tougher time, other things being equal. Race-based discrimination, whether supposedly for or against blacks, does not actually provide value for blacks in general in the long run, and neither does it provide value for non-blacks. As a side note, other things are not equal. For instance, coming from an abusive family in America is probably much more of a disadvantage than being black. We need to stop fetishizing race in particular.
- SwellJoe 13y ago"We need to stop fetishizing race in particular." Who is "festishizing race"? And, what does that phrase mean in this context? Do you believe I'm fetishizing race? Or OP? Or some other comment in this thread? I'm merely saying that to insist that race not be part of the conversation is a passive approach to maintaining the status quo. Or, to quote Elie Wiesel: "We must always take sides. Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the victim."
- ricardobeat 13y agoBut this is not a fight, or it shouldn't be. There is no need to "take sides". The pattern of under-represented ethnicities can be seen all over, should it be brought up in every conversation? It is a reflex of beliefs and behaviours in our society that we want to get rid of, not perpetuate. Encouraging people to discriminate based on race would be the status quo, ignoring it is the exact opposite.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agostatus quo? Are you talking about your parents' generation? I don't recall such an incident in my experience in the last few decades. Maybe I'm just sheltered or something; make up your own excuse to ignore me. But I think there's a generation who's made real progress. I would think the conversation would change; but I guess its easier to just repeat the same diatribe than draw from your own experiences or statistics or something solid?
- ricardobeat 13y agoJust following the parent's train of thought. I agree.
- SwellJoe 13y ago"The pattern of under-represented ethnicities can be seen all over, should it be brought up in every conversation?" In every conversation? No. In a conversation about the under-representation of minorities in tech? Yes. "Encouraging people to discriminate based on race is the status quo, ignoring it is the exact opposite." Ignoring oppression is not the opposite. It is the tacit approval of oppression.
- pessimizer 13y agoI think it's respectful to call people what they wish to be called. If someone prefers to be called "African-American," calling them that has nothing to do with political correctness, it has to do with the person standing in front of you.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- wcummings 13y agoThe problem is when people use it as a synonym for black. For example, a Jamaican immigrant would not be African-American, and a white South African would be. No one considers black an offensive term, and in many cases "African-American" is clunky and imprecise, for example this thread. OP is really asking about black founders.
- pessimizer 13y agoThat's just a mistake. I'm pretty sure that there aren't many black non-Americans asking to be called African-American. >white South African would be. The "African" in "African-American" has nothing to do with where you were born or where your parents were born, just like the "Free" in "Free Software" has nothing to do with beer. It has to do with the origin of the features that make you distinct (in a historically particular way) from white Americans. Of course, if white Africans who move to America identify as African-Americans, it's certainly their right, and I'd gladly refer to them as that.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Radzell 13y agoAfrican american invented the word 100 years ago. It's what we chose to be called. The other -American are disrespectful. It shows a lack of awareness of what the original term stood for.