3 ms·
In one of the other threads, some stated that Google do not have monopoly status. The claim they used was that google only has 25% of the search market. This t
by belorn 13y ago
In one of the other threads, some stated that Google do not have monopoly status. The claim they used was that google only has 25% of the search market.
This topic is interesting because it shows how much in a monopoly status google really is in in controlling where traffic goes on the net.
- res0nat0r 13y agoI'd replace the word monopoly with popular.
- belorn 13y ago"A monopoly (from Greek monos μόνος (alone or single) + polein πωλεῖν (to sell)) exists when a specific person or enterprise is the only supplier of a particular commodity. Monopolies are thus characterized by a lack of economic competition to produce the good or service and a lack of viable substitute goods. The verb "monopolize" refers to the process by which a company gains the ability to raise prices or exclude competitors." - Wikipedia You can monopolize an market by popularity, and thus create a monopoly. However, monopoly and popularity is not the same word.
- res0nat0r 13y agoGoogle is not the only supplier to internet searches and is not excluding competitors. They are merely very popular and are thus not a monopoly.
- throwawaykf03 13y agoYou are interpreting "monopoly" literally. In the context of antitrust law, you only need to have a big enough market share to appear on regulators' radars. The actual market share threshold varies from country to country, but typically it's around 60%. Google certainly meets that criteria in many countries, not only for search but for online video as well. As for "excluding competitors", Google is having a tough time with antitrust regulators in the EU for exactly that. For a more obvious example, see their shenanigans with YouTube and Windows Phone.
- crazy1van 13y agoI totally don't buy that Google has a monopoly on search. Anyone here could start a search engine tomorrow. Sure, it might suck, but there is no barrier to entry. It isn't like Ma Bell telephone companies who had blocked other competitors from running copper wires to homes via tons of local ordinances... which reminds me, its pretty hard to have a true monopoly without some help from the government.
- angryasian 13y agoyou are not using that word correctly. If Google was the only company doing search and prevented others from entering the market you would be correct. Being the best through a superior product and innovating is not a monopoly.
- gojomo 13y agoDoesn't matter how you achieve a monopoly: it's defined by dominance, not bad-behavior. And once you have monopoly power, things that used to be legal for you to do – for example certain pricing or bundling strategies – can become illegal.
- angryasian 13y agothe entire argument is questionable as to what Google's strategy is but they are only in that position because of a superior product in a market with a relatively low barrier.
- gojomo 13y agoLow barrier?! Giant companies like Yahoo, staffed with large teams of search technology pioneers, have been scared out of search competition. Google touts its massive custom infrastructure. The arms race between Google and SEO creates a massive pollution backwash of false quality signals on the web, that make things way harder for any upstart which lacks Google's decade-plus of proprietary know-how and billions in hardware. And that's before considering the contractual defaults across software (Firefox/toolbars/bundleware) and subsidized hardware (Android), that few people change. (Many don't even know it can be changed, or don't even know the difference between "Google" and "the Internet"!) Those are all big barriers to entry, even if they've been earned by excellent technology and business strategy.
- angryasian 13y agowhile DDG started by 1 guy and entrants like blekko or qwiki can differentiate in other ways and enter and compete easily. Again everything you are saying is because of superior product/employees and innovation. Your entire argument is based off no one else can come up with a better product so lets punish them
- gojomo 13y agoInteresting point! Google's search team has been famously resistant to any influence by Google's sales/marketing teams on ranking decisions. Search quality gave rise to the 'golden goose', after all, and the self-conception of the team, and its individual members, is based on independence from purely money-grubbing considerations. But I wonder, what happens when Google's antitrust lawyers came to the ranking team, and say: "soften this penalty [or otherwise tweak these quality-rankings], because otherwise we'll be in more trouble with regulators or leave too much evidence of market-power." Could the search team still say, "buzz off, we're sticking to what we know from the numbers is what's best for our users"? Or does keeping regulators happy, and avoiding smoking-gun fact-patterns, trump everything? I suspect it often will, because of the unique risks of state enforcement and appearing unlawful. It's also easier to rationalize "we're sacrificing our own idea of what's best because the law seems to require it" (even if the actual risk is fuzzy before losing in a formal legal process) than "we're doing this to make the guys over in ads/mobile/etc a bit more money this quarter".
- dragonwriter 13y ago> This topic is interesting because it shows how much in a monopoly status google really is in in controlling where traffic goes on the net. Does it? I mean, is there any reason to believe that Rap Genius is typical in their degree of dependence on Google here?