4 ms·
As a former 12 year old boy, I don't understand why people are so adamant to protect children from sexual content. When you're old enough to know what you're lo
by Swizec 13y ago
As a former 12 year old boy, I don't understand why people are so adamant to protect children from sexual content. When you're old enough to know what you're looking at, it is all you want to look at and you will seek it out no matter what. Personally I used to browse between channels on the telly to get super grainy glimpses of porn. When that wasn't available and after our phone got blocked from calling hotlines, I would simply draw naked women for myself to look at.
When you aren't old enough to know what you're looking at, you won't really care about what you see and won't think twice about it. But really if you're older than, say, 6 or 7 you should know what sex is and how it works. Intellectually speaking at least. You won't really care for seeing porn because, well, LEGOs are far more interesting.
So really, I think all this "shield children omg" isn't so much about shielding children as it is about certain adults being obnoxious prudes and using children as an excuse to get their way.
- DanBC 13y ago> Personally I used to browse between channels on the telly to get super grainy glimpses of porn. When that wasn't available and after our phone got blocked from calling hotlines, I would simply draw naked women for myself to look at. You can't see a difference between grainy glimpses of softcore porn or hand drawn images, and high definition easily available images of heavy duty porn?
- dkuntz2 13y agoPersonally, not particularly. Sure they're different, but it's not for the government to decide that they should be blocked, especially if it's legal for a portion of the populace to view them. If a parent doesn't want a child to view material of that nature (or any nature) it should be up to the parent, not the state, to make sure their child doesn't view it or have access to it. There's commercially available software out there that can make the same blocks, but it's opt-in. The issue isn't that "kids should be able to see what kids want to see", it's "the state shouldn't dictate people can or can't see in the privacy of their home".
- DanBC 13y agoYou realise that the state isn't dictating what people can or can't see - these filters are optional? And that for existing customers they default to opt-in? It's frustrating that the reason the government forced ISP filtering is because i) no-one uses parental filtering and ii) parental filtering is hopeless.
- summerdown2 13y agoThe filters aren't optional. Setting them to "on" or "off" is currently optional, but the traffic of everyone in the country will soon pass through these filtering machines.
- Swizec 13y agoThey weren't softcore. And the happiest day of my life was when one of my friends got internet and learned how to find porn on Emule. That was amazing. You can't imagine how happy a group of 13 to 14 year old boys is when they get their hands on a resource like that ... then they go off and play with LEGOs and toy cars and watching MTV for the sexual content. Yes, I used to fap to MTV. And no adult ever thinks of MTV like that. Should we ban it?
- hawkharris 13y agoAs a fellow former 12-year-old boy, I agree that shielding children from legal sexual images doesn't usually serve a purpose other than to deprive them of an education. We wouldn't restrict kids' access to math materials, then expect them to know calculus as adults. Similarly, kids who are banned from talking about and seeing sexual content can't be expected to understand sexual health. From an objective standpoint, the interesting question is whether or not exposure to sexual content at early ages is harmful to children. I did some cursory research on this in college and found that: a) There seems to a big problem with bias in studies concerning sex and adolescents. Even some of the most frequently cited studies use biased language (e.g. abstracts with the phrase "the problem of children viewing sex"). b) A major variable is whether or not parents are there to mediate the kids' exposure to sexual content — not just to restrict their access, but to provide context. To use the math analogy again, it's like the difference between explaining a chapter or dumping worksheets and a textbook on the table.
- Swizec 13y ago> b) A major variable is whether or not parents are there to mediate the kids' exposure to sexual content This. A thousand times this. Kids need someone to explain what they're seeing, not someone to flat out restrict it. You wouldn't let your kid watch a grizzly war movie without explaining to them that it's a movie, that these sort of things happened and war is terrible, and that they're reasonably safe from these things happening to them if they're from the western world. But heaven forbid you explain to your kid what sex is and how it works and that it's awesome. Oh no that's way too awkward. (usually because the adults in question aren't emotionally mature enough themselves)