4 ms·
It's far less useful to check your privilege than it is to check if the arguments are correct. The former is an easy way to dismiss an argument without actuall
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
It's far less useful to check your privilege than it is to check if the arguments are correct.
The former is an easy way to dismiss an argument without actually reading it. The latter requires careful thought and runs the risk that you might realize you are incorrect.
- rosser 13y agoI disagree. Even if you're fallaciously occasioned to "check your privilege", it's still a useful exercise. And doesn't writing off all such invocations make you guilty of the same kind of prejudicial dismissal you're arguing against, anyway?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoSo what? A privileged person can be correct, and an unprivileged one can be wrong. What do you gain by checking your privilege over checking your reasoning/facts?
- rosser 13y agoThey aren't mutually exclusive. In fact, they're often the very same thing. (Edit: though it's perhaps more about checking premises than argument in many cases.) Consider my original comment in this thread: is it not the case that the kinds of labor leverage that software people have aren't shared by everyone else? Is it not therefore the case that the kinds of libertarianism espoused by so many software people, premised at least in part on that leverage, don't apply to everyone else as much as they seem to think? I submit that if the developers espousing those fallaciously premised flavors of libertarianism were (able) to "check their privilege", they'd arrive at different conclusions.