3 ms·
Ask HN: Who can see individual upvote data?
This isn't about HN, but even in general, what kind of protections do you expect with things like upvotes?
Do you consider whether your upvotes are tracked?
How often are upvotes tied to personalized ads in some way?
Could upvote history, or even derivative or aggregated data, be sold to third parties? Used internally? Subpoenaed by the courts?
Any links to worthwhile existing discussions on topic would be greatly appreciated.
- zaroth 13y ago14 upvotes, 0 comments, and for some reason, totally missing from the 'Ask' page. My strangest 'Ask HN' ever...
- seiji 13y agoOn this site, you can see every story somebody has submitted or upvoted by going to their profile. The comments someone up/downvotes isn't available publicly, but I assume it's kept on the backend. I think the noise in a simple upvote action is too much for any legal meaning though. You can't tell if somebody upvoted for agreement or humor (poe's law) or upvoted out of friendship (voting rings) with no cares at all. On Facebook, we know their upvotes ("likes" they say) are used for tracking and manipulating everything you do — informing your news, tracking you across the webternet, logging your interests. But, there too, the upvote is ambiguous. If you upvote "X died" does it mean you like that they died or you you're showing compassion? Now, with Slashdot moderation, user upvote could be more useful assuming the user isn't lying, but nothing supports slashdot-like moderation anywhere else. Ain't nobody got time for quantized sentiment decisions.
- maxerickson 13y agoHn story up votes are not visible to other users.
- zaroth 13y agoI wonder if we'll ever see these sites offered a forwarding service - you choose a submission and pay a fee and you get a randomly generated forwarding address which lets you send an email to the people who up voted that story (without learning their email address)
- seiji 13y agoThat's what a facebook like is, isn't it? A way to get the user to indirectly opt in to future marketing materials. When it started, nobody realized that's what would happen.