5 ms·
Funny, my experience is the opposite on literally every concrete assertion about people and motivations. Looking at my team, and the broader team under my dire
by luu 13y ago
Funny, my experience is the opposite on literally every concrete assertion about people and motivations.
Looking at my team, and the broader team under my director, only one was hired "straight out of college". Well, if you consider fresh PhDs to be "straight out of college", there are a few, but I doubt Aaron meant folks approaching 30 with kids on the horizon when he was talking about people just out of college.
Perhaps a couple are cynical, but I wouldn't call any childish or enthusiastically adolescent, which isn't too surprising, considering that the median employee within two levels of management of me is mid-thirties with two kids.
We have a couple of visiting scientists (professors at major research universities), and they were surprised by what we're doing, so perhaps the secrecy doesn't do such a bad job of keeping things inside the company after all.
I don't doubt Aaron's experience, but it's exactly what you'd expect due to selection bias. How old was Aaron when he wrote that, 20? He probably wasn't hanging out with the median person from my team. There's nothing wrong with that. But, all things considered, that essay contains a lot of awfully strong assertions.
- presorted 13y agoBeing infantile means that you are an adult that behaves regressively. People with kids, and in their mid-thirties, can be infantile. I think that Aaron knew what he was saying. The problem is how do you judge whether someone is infantile, because you must either judge relative to yourself, or relative to a role model. If we are to believe Aaron, then we must believe that he could distinguish between a mature adult and regressive behavior --- and if we are to believe you, then we must believe the same of you. And if I'm to play the judge, then I need to know this myself, and I've found it to be a complex topic, and since it involves growth, it is a lifelong pursuit. Perhaps the one objective statement we can make is that we eventually must become independent of our parents and the safety of the parental home.
- madaxe_again 13y agoI'm personally aware of a very incapable 22 year old, fresh graduate, who has been hired for north of $200k. I'm also aware of a whole bunch of other folks who have been variously hired within months of graduation, so I'd wager there's some selection bias from your corner too.
- pvdm 13y agofreudian slip ?
- madaxe_again 13y agoBeg pardon?
- pvdm 13y agoyou mean capable, right ?
- madaxe_again 13y agoNo, sadly. This person cannot think their way out of a paper bag. There must be some talent I'm missing, but in a decade of knowing them I've not seen it. Bit mystifying as the role is secret.
- cromwellian 13y agoBase salary? Unless said 22yr old had done some significant research, had an awesome open source project, is an all star Phd, then I'm temped to call bullshit on this one, and your acquaintance is blowing smoke up your ass. $200k base salary puts you into Level senior staff engineer/director software engineer territory. Most college grads AFAIK are slotted at 3-4 slots slower. You're effectively saying the person your aware of was hired almost as a Director level engineer at age 22. Most high level Google engineers are promoted at this level because of the cross-functional aspects of their experience -- they've taken the lead on several mid to large projects and worked across many Google product areas/teams. Experience impossible to achieve in college. To give you perspective, I've seen CEO and CTOs of acquired startups in the $50-100 million range can land at mid level engineering levels at Google. If incompetent people with no experience are landing director level jobs @ $200k base salary as a common practice at Google, I want in on this scam!
- madaxe_again 13y ago
- perrylaj 13y agoI am not a Googler, nor do I know too many, but the thing that jumps out at me is that the blog post is from 2006. A lot has changed around SV/tech since then, and even more specifically, the size, culture and focus of Google appears quite different from the outside. Google wasn't exactly a startup in 2006, but was still closer to its roots (and only 2 years into its public status). I won't pretend to know how accurate his portrayal is then, or how it is now, but I wouldn't be surprised if a time machine did show a different culture then and now.