4 ms·
No one is missing out, at least not yet, and I don't think they'll miss out any time soon. I say this as a person who has a Nest thermostat, Philips Hue lights,
by mikestew 13y ago
No one is missing out, at least not yet, and I don't think they'll miss out any time soon. I say this as a person who has a Nest thermostat, Philips Hue lights, and a Nissan Leaf. All of those items can be remotely accessed with my phone. I've never fiddled with the Nest when I'm not home (turned the heat down from bed once. Once, because I could.) With the lights I have no choice but to control them from the phone. But that was my choice to buy lights that require a computer to control. I can remotely turn the heat or A/C on in the Leaf, start charging, or check status. When the free 3 years is up on that feature, I would only pay a pittance to continue service.
Let's also consider that the Nest is $279, the Hue lights run $60 per bulb, and the Leaf is a $30K car (all in USD). If you can afford those, you can afford an iPhone.
The author thinks there's a gap that doesn't exist, and my guess is that is because he lives surrounded by that remotely-controlled world (and perhaps helps create products to fit that world). Let me give another side to it: it's a pain in the ass. Fire up the phone, unlock it, go find the app, fiddle with the controls...all to just turn on a light in the living room or turn up the heat. Yes, pity the po' folk who are reduced to walking over and flipping a light switch.
No one is missing out. The title is accurate in the app-controlled world is closed to those without the devices. But I don't buy the argument that one gains an advantage by living in that world. As it stands now, it's a nice-to-have world of expensive devices that fit well with the smartphone you already have. Let's wring our hands when app-only devices like door locks and thermostats become commodities and the devices to control them are still expensive. I predict it won't happen, as the price of smart door locks comes down so will the price of smartphones.
- dkokelley 13y agoI agree with your point, although I think you miss the author's point slightly. In our personal lives, the choice to buy the cheap analog version of things is still an option, while those of us with access to technology can leverage it in a way that makes our lives easier. This "widens the gap" between the haves and have-nots. At the same time, as technology advances, tools and services that the poor relied on (e.g. payphones, print newspapers, and coin-operated parking meters) are declining in availability. There is an ever-increasing pressure on people to adopt new technology, and those who can't afford to must find ways to work around these limits. In a way, we already live in the world described in the article. Imagine the impact on cars when they first arrived. "The wealthy can afford to take jobs farther away, while the poor are limited to work only as far as they can walk!" Having the perspective of a century of progress, I can tell you the impact, and I doubt many would argue that automobiles are a net loss to society. Unfortunately it sometimes seems like the only equitable solution is to restrict the use of technology so that those without it are not too disadvantaged (i.e. "If we limit cars to walking speed, everyone will have the same job opportunities").
- mikestew 13y agoRather than miss the point, I think I just avoided it. I guess it was the opening ("we can unlock our doors with a phone, but what about the poor?") and his implication that it will all soon be nothing but iPhones (because that's the biggest market, the author alleges, which isn't even accurate if one isn't selling the app itself for money). > At the same time, as technology advances, tools and services that the poor relied on (e.g. payphones, print newspapers, and coin-operated parking meters) are declining in availability. Those are actually good examples that are actually being displaced and for which no cheap option exists, and might have better made the author's point in the opening. I just don't see cheap lightbulbs being displaced by $60 Hue bulbs any time soon. Thanks for the differing perspective.