4 ms·
[Judge Leon] found the program’s invasion of privacy especially troubling given the “utter lack of evidence that a terrorist attack has ever been prevented" I
by ams6110 13y ago
[Judge Leon] found the program’s invasion of privacy especially troubling given the “utter lack of evidence that a terrorist attack has ever been prevented"
I find it troubling that judges are considering a benefit such as crime reduction in considering right-to-privacy issues. Certainly many crimes might be prevented if we did away with the constitutional rights of the accused, restrictions on search and seizure, etc. but is that the world we want to live in? Do we all want to be subject to random, warrantless searches of our homes, computers, or bodies, or warrantless arrest and interrogation, if the net result is a reduction in crime?
The classic Benjamin Franklin quote comes to mind here.
- nitid_name 13y agoThere is a balance between privacy and crime reduction already codified into law and common law. See: the use of snoopers and other IR devices to look for grow houses (generally accepted as unreasonable) and the use of airborne BAC sensors to look for drunk drivers (generally accepted as reasonable) Legal decisions are about balance between individual rights and group rights. Free speech vs "fire in a crowded theater" is a classic example of this balancing act.