5 ms·
Now, some people like to think that stuff like "technology always improves in time to save us" is some kind of natural law. I guess they are more into science a
by CamperBob2 13y ago
Now, some people like to think that stuff like "technology always improves in time to save us" is some kind of natural law. I guess they are more into science as religion, than in science as science.
(Shrug) On the one side, we have some people who have always said that. They have always been right.
On the other side, we have some people who have always forecast an imminent heat death of Malthusian malaise for us all. Those people have never been right, so I'd say they bear the burden of proof that This Time It's Different.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y agoStein's Law: If something cannot go on forever, it will stop. The only thing that's guaranteed when consuming a finite resource at an accelerating rate is that sooner or later, It Will Be Different.
- CamperBob2 13y agoBut being right at the wrong time is no better, and often worse, than being flat-out wrong.
- caoilte 13y agoSometimes being right at the wrong time is better. Maybe we are only alive today because so many of our parents predicted Nuclear Armageddon and acted to prevent it? It always depends. Every situation is different and it always boils down to a risk assessment. We have to make a collective call on whether the risks of doing nothing outweigh the benefits. Unfortunately we can't rely on our current obsession: "the markets" to make an accurate risk assessment for us. Markets and oligarchies (and darwinism for that matter) operate within established patterns. They optimize and specialise for short term success. It takes external pressures to implement transformative change. That external pressure will either be uncomfortably "communist" or the "creative destruction" of a global bloodletting that destroys most of our ecosystems.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y agoWorse for what? If you're gambling on the stock market then sure it's worse for you. If you're wanting to keep civilisation functioning well, then no; taking precautions is not worse for us.
- CamperBob2 13y agotaking precautions is not worse for us. Are you naive enough to assume that all effects of "precautions" are necessarily benign?
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y agoInsult + straw man position. Not worthy of a serious reply.
- baq 13y agoselection bias. look up civilizations other than the one we live in currently, e.g. the mayans.
- CamperBob2 13y agoThe Mayans ran out of oil?
- llamataboot 13y agoFirst off, it is not running out of something that is nec the problem, just the drop in ROI can be devastating. Secondly, the Mayans ran out of corn.
- jjoonathan 13y agoNo, but they might have run out of a critical resource that they didn't expect to run out of. There doesn't seem to be much agreement on exactly what caused the collapse (judging from the wiki article), so it's not a great example.
- olefoo 13y agoActually the classic study is the Rapa Nui culture who inhabited Easter Island and whose culture had already been decimated by deforestation when the Europeans arrived. Jared Diamond's book Collapse is an exploration of the phenomenon. A bit hard to read if you're paying attention.
- baq 13y agooh yes that's a much better example, thank you.
- waps 13y agoReally ? Where were the technological improvements when oil shot up to $150 in 2008 ? Sure technological improvements eventually got us to the energy level we were at in 2005 ... but only just barely and only for a week. Since then it's been going down, with predictable results. And while shale (currently) provides a few years delay, it's only for a few years, and maybe even only America. That's the problem with these ass-saving technologies. The first few times they saved our ass for several centuries (coal + trains, which will keep working, later nuclear). The next revolution saved our collective energy-hogging asses for ~60 years. The next one, horizontal drilling, did for ~10-15 years. Now we have shale oil, which saves our asses for 5-6 years tops. The situation is not as rosy as you indicate at all. We're effectively dependent on ALL technologies operating at totally maxed out capacity for economic prosperity, and a lot of these technologies are faltering all at the same time. It won't be pretty. Frankly we have ~5 years to increase the efficiency of batteries (which have improved a factor 2 in ~100 years in mass/energy and volume/energy). Not by a factor of 2, but a factor of 10, to keep our society at the same technological level. Nobody has any even theoretical ideas to get a twofold improvement. We only have 5 years because of shale oil, and we knew perfectly well in 2000 that we'd need this super-battery before the decade was out, and humanity simply failed ... I went to a robotic mechanics lecture 2 years ago. The opening line was this : you climbed 5 floors to get here, and you got seriously tired (the elevators were out). If you had been the best robot we have, with roughly half it's weight dedicated to battery you would have just used ~50% of the total energy contents of your battery. This is a problem that needs to be solved before we have any real hope of true independent robots. Oh and let's feel inspired by nature. Wait. How does nature solve this ? Well, here's the basic formula for oil CnH2n+2. Here's the basic formula for human fat : CnH2nOOH. In both cases the energy is stored in the same chemical structure. The energy is pretty much stored in the exact same chemical bonds in the human body (or any animal) and in a gas tank. In other words : in 4 billion years evolution did not find a better way. Do you think humanity is likely to improve upon it ? You best hope so. Or we'll see repeats of 2008, except without recovery.
- fauigerzigerk 13y agoThere's not just the energy production and storage side of the equation. Technologies that increase engery efficiency are advancing pretty rapidly right now, in spite of the fact that energy cost is a much smaller share of GDP than it used to be. I am confident that peak consumption will outrun peak production and that we have a lot of leeway to reduce consumption even more quickly without making major changes to our way of life.
- w0utert 13y ago>> On the other side, we have some people who have always forecast an imminent heat death of Malthusian malaise for us all. Those people have never been right I'd argue that for a very large part of the global population, maybe even the majority, life as they know is, is pretty close to a Malthusian malaise, and has been for ages.
- coldtea 13y ago>On the other side, we have some people who have always forecast an imminent heat death of Malthusian malaise for us all. Those people have never been right, so I'd say they bear the burden of proof that This Time It's Different. Never been right? They'd been right in predicting the Big Depression. They'd been right saying this "gold rush" thing was BS. Heck, there were people who predicted the decline and fall of Rome quite accurately. There were people who predicted the dot-com bust quite adequately. There were people who warned about the dangers of Nazi germany (or even the dangers of the Versailles treaty) before it was even a consideration for most. There were people who warned about the housing market bubble quite adequately. Now, as for why those people (doing the warning) might seem to be wrong more often that others saying it's all OK. Consider someone playing russian roulette -- perhaps with a 20 bullet chamber. Some other guy warns him: what are you doing, are you crazy? But he pulls the trigger and nothing happens. The other guy warns him again, stop it man, you'll kill yourself. Again, nothing happens. This goes on for a while, until at some point, say the 14th try, the guy blows his brains out. Well, this same thing happened with situations like the recent economic crash. Now, some people view it like the person giving the warning was wrong 13 times, and only right once. They'll say, dismisingly, "Well of course he eventually got it right: he always kept to the same warning even when he was wrong. Even a broken watch tells the right time 2 times a day, etc". But I'd argue that that person was right ALL ALONG. Even when nothing had yet happened. And that if some other kind of action was chosen as he warned it should be (e.g putting the gun down), the tragedy would have been avoided.
- CamperBob2 13y agoAnd we got over all that stuff, and emerged stronger. The Russian Roulette analogy is not applicable because we're not discussing random processes.
- coldtea 13y ago>And we got over all that stuff, and emerged stronger. What, out of the recession? That's fairy tale level denial. The thing is still going strong, and it's not even close to over yet. Neither is the US economy coming out stonger at this point. >The Russian Roulette analogy is not applicable because we're not discussing random processes. Actually it's perfectly applicable. For one, the processes we're discussing are essentially stochastic -- there are so many random factors playing into the economy at any given time. Second, as with the russian roulette, the long term result after a specific consistent course of action is extremely deterministic (you blow your brains in one case, or you fuck up the economy in the other).