4 ms·
This is the same argument as the long running feud between the 2 famous billiards players Willie Mosconi and Minnesota Fats. Willie was world champion and had
by edw519 17y ago
This is the same argument as the long running feud between the 2 famous billiards players Willie Mosconi and Minnesota Fats. Willie was world champion and had won many tournaments. Fats never won any championships, but won a small fortune playing for money. When they played each other, Willie creamed Fats, to which Fats responded, "Big deal, how much money did he win?"
Computer science is Willie. Software engineering is Fats. It may not be elegant and precise, but it gets the job done and earns lunch.
- sb 17y agothere is also a very good movie (the hustler, paul newman + jackie gleason) concerning these two characters. however, the movie connections aside -- i am not buying this "sw-engineering" equals "it's a paycheck"-mentality. IMHO, the two disciplines are not easily comparable, this mostly stems from the fact that CS deals with "computing in the small", while SWE deals with "computing in the large" (actually, more "programming" than "computing"). i think this is also a major reason that research areas in both disciplines are not overlapping (aside from code generation which obviously uses theory from compilers, i am mostly thinking in terms of product-lines and variability-handling; please post if you have other areas in mind that i fail to remember ad hoc) also please note: the mutual disregard for CS towards SWE and vice versa is actually counterproductive and i am sure that some interdisciplinary efforts could be mutually beneficial...
- tybris 17y agoI think he refers to the "scientific" discipline of Software Engineering, which earns you no more lunches (probably fewer) than creating algorithms.
- scott_s 17y agoThat comparison makes no sense to me. Software engineering is to computer science as mechanical engineering is to physics. They're not in a competition.
- miloshh 17y agoThe only problem with that comparison is that Willie does not help Fats to get his fortune at all. However, software engineering heavily depends on and benefits from computer science.