2 ms·
> it lumps into a single giant structure every possibly imaginable number. What? There are several different numeric types. It's there to implement more advanc
by lispm 13y ago
> it lumps into a single giant structure every possibly imaginable number.
What? There are several different numeric types. It's there to implement more advanced mathematics capabilities.
Like in Axiom, which runs on top of Common Lisp.
> Haskell's relatively fine-grained distinctions between numeric types is nothing like Lisp's numeric tower.
Haskell's numeric capabilities were in part copied from Common Lisp.
- catnaroek 13y ago> What? There are several different numeric types. It's there to implement more advanced mathematics capabilities. There is no such thing as multiple types in Common Lisp. > Haskell's numeric capabilities were in part copied from Common Lisp. Haskell's standard type classes include the notions of ring (Num), field (Fractional* ) and integer (Integral). (Notably absent is the notion of semiring, which would be useful for a type of natural numbers, though.) The importance of making these distinctions is that you can statically ensure that you are using certain algebraic structures but not others. * Somehow floating points were invited to the party, but, hey! I guess no standard library can be perfect.
- lispm 13y agoFor most practical applications this is not necessary at all. Common Lisp has countless mathematical applications which make use of its various numeric data types.
- catnaroek 13y agoWe are using different notions of type. For me, a type is a static guarantee about the meaning of a syntactic term in the program, rather than a mere labelling of values during the runtine process. In the sense of type that I use, Common Lisp does not have but just one type, and it is not even a type of numbers - it is a type of everything. All in all, I did not intend to overly diss Common Lisp. It is a very flexible, expressive and powerful language. I am just saying that, at least from my point of view, Common Lisp does not look particularly inspired by mathematics.