4 ms·
Its a fair trade. The cost to society of a large dilbertian corporation is very high in terms of lowered quality of life. Yes some rich people get richer, but
by VLM 13y ago
Its a fair trade. The cost to society of a large dilbertian corporation is very high in terms of lowered quality of life. Yes some rich people get richer, but that doesn't mean quality of life isn't, on average for the society, reduced. So it seems perfectly fair that a tax or charge or bill be presented.
The USA situation relates to only about 60% of the population having a job, so 40% don't need "leave" anyway, and the percentage of people having a job is in permanent multi decade decline. So if there's not enough jobs right now to keep two parents fully employed at their appropriate level, there seems little point in encouraging both to work. If the powers that be do not permit your social group to have a career then there seems little point in complaining about a minor detail standing in the way of a career, which you can't have anyway regardless of popping out kids or not.
The USA situation for paternal leave is also screwed up for multicultural reasons and history of racism reasons. We have ethnic groups where the percentage of babies born to unwed mothers is way over majority, and uncle sam is the sugar "daddy". So allowing married fathers to take paid time off is going to make a huge mess where certain minorities are going to complain about their unmarried men not getting time off, but the white guys do get time off. I suppose you could demand a copy of the birth cert, so at least one baby couldn't result in ten guys claiming vacation time as father for each kid? Regardless of details and stats, there would be racial / socioeconomic friction in the USA about the whole topic that doesn't exist in a monocultural nation like, say, Japan.
Some cultures are built around the idea of supporting that culture, whereas the USA is built around the idea of convincing everyone that its an optimum strategy for every subculture to screw over every subculture; of course that means everyone gets screwed over in the end, but as long as you can convince the idiots its scalable, it'll be a profitable scam to run. Divide and conqueor, baby!
- philwelch 13y agoLarge corporations reduce quality of life? Bullshit. How do you figure that? At worst, maybe they don't improve quality of life as much as you think they should but if they actively reduced quality of life people wouldn't voluntarily choose to work for them or buy from them.
- VLM 13y agoMerger of large .com and .gov ruining .gov for everyone, environmental damage for everyone not just stockholders, lack of economic agility / flexibility ruining economic conditions for everyone else, the previously mentioned Dilbertian damage to culture and lifestyle impacting to some extent everyone, obvious lifestyle problems like traffic jams and parking lots and general commuter lifestyle negatively impacting everyone... (also edited to add the larger one player is, the less of a free market exists for everyone else, so lack of competition ruins the marketplace for everyone) Simply calculate the ratio of people claiming in public that they wanna work at a smaller company vs wanting to work at a larger company. HN is not representative in general, but in this specific example no one really wants to work at Innitech from the Office Space movie. Or the total aggregate of whining about working conditions about dilbertian megacorp inc vs smaller more flexible companies. So, you wanna run a zoo.. Well OK. Nothing wrong with keeping both giant Elephants and tiny little Meerkats, in fact some diversity is an excellent idea. They're each cool in their own way. But its ignoring reality to not accept that the giant elephant exhibit is going to produce somewhat more smelly biological solid waste than the tiny little Meerkat exhibit.
- philwelch 13y agoIf large companies were actually making things worse, then just getting rid of them would be sufficient to make things better. That's the definition of making something worse. So tell me: would getting rid of large companies make things better or not?
- VLM 13y agoIt would make things better for the general public due to increased competition, better working conditions, and faster more agile innovation. It would make things worse for the stockholders and politicians relying on political contributions from those individuals. There is a natural lack of scalability of the number of competing firms because most line of business have an inherent minimal size; if it takes 20 people to run a 1000 foot long printing press, shrinking the firm below 20 or so suddenly starts making things worse not better. Another good example would be a mine. It doesn't seem terribly controversial that there exists a maxima in total human happiness where average business size is a vaguely tribal number depending on individual line of business. The other extreme of infinity sized firms or 100% of the population is just re-imagined communism or feudalism and its not overly controversial to claim that historically those systems really sucked.