10 ms·
They certainly are too big to fail. Do you really think the government would take steps that would lead to Wal-Mart going out of business and putting those mill
by bradleyjg 13y ago
They certainly are too big to fail. Do you really think the government would take steps that would lead to Wal-Mart going out of business and putting those million people out of work, and the communities that depend on Wal-Mart for retail service and tax revenue, in the lurch? I don't.
Wal-Mart is TBTF, the question is whether there's anything the government could do that would cause it to catastrophically fail (and thus whether or not there's a moral hazard involved). In the case of Anderson, the government indictment killed the firm because no one wanted to be audited by a firm indicted for fraud. In the case of banks, there are automatic sanctions that go into place upon a criminal conviction that would constrict the ability of the bank to access capital markets, and thus could conceivably lead to rapid collapse. It's hard to see anything similar that could be done to Wal-Mart. If convicted of a crime most likely it would just pay whatever the fine was and keep doing business.
On the other hand, take a business like Boeing -- that's both TBTF, largely because of it's giant workforce, and vulnerable to rapid collapse if government sanctions, such as those stemming from criminal conviction, made it ineligible for US government contracts (such contracts make up around 40% of revenue).
As for the grandparent's proposal rather than a hard cap, I'd prefer to see some sort of feedback mechanism to counteract natural economy of scale effects. Perhaps some sort of escalating tax rate (per employee maybe or some combination of employee and revenue). For industries like banking with acute dangers something more tailored might be in order -- taking into account balance sheet size, nominal outstanding transactions, and counterparty centrality.