3 ms·
Some musings on mathematics
- tokenadult 13y agoA previous discussion[1] 11 months ago (no comments): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5008412 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5008412 There are some older submissions too, with a few comments each. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1071734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1071734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2264243 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2264243 (this one later went dead) I like the series this comes from, but I'm not competent to make an informed comment on the substance of this interesting post. [1] Colin, you know I just had to do that whenever I see you submit something that has been submitted before.
- j2kun 13y agoI think many mathematicians would argue that there's an additional component of aesthetics at play. It's not just that you want to know whether a theorem is true (in fact, nobody cares whether the theorem is true). You want to know why, and you want the proof to be so trivial that in hindsight it's obvious. This is why people build up grand theories, so that when they get to the mean value theorem they can just say "Tilt your head and apply Rolle's theorem!" It's proofs that mathematicians are after, not answers, and beautiful proofs at that.
- JadeNB 13y ago> You want to know why, and you want the proof to be so trivial that in hindsight it's obvious. Certainly I agree with the first part of this sentence, but I'm not sure about the second part. I think that, if this is accomplished, then it is viewed as a victory; but I don't think any mathematician would describe it as his or her mission. (Perhaps on a larger scale, the mission of mathematics is to find the right definitions that make previously difficult things obvious.)
- j2kun 13y agoThe parenthetical is what I meant by my sentence. But also to a lesser extent Paul Erdos was a famous proponent of always finding simpler and more obvious proofs.
- lmm 13y agoI never like this "want to solve equations" narrative. Maybe some equations just don't have a solution; advanced mathematicians know why it's nice to work with an algebraically closed field, but it's not at all obvious. The example about convergent sequences is much more useful; intuitively it seems wrong that we should be able to write a "smooth" function like sqrt(x - 2) and see that it's above zero for some values of x, below zero for other values of x, and never pass through zero. The historical invention of complex numbers wasn't to solve equations that had no solution; it was as an intermediate step, a tool, when applying the cubic formula. Likewise I suspect that fractions and negative numbers were invented not to solve equations that couldn't be solved, but so that the rules of arithmetic worked for expressions like "5 + 3 - 6". (I actually agree with the main idea, but I don't think these examples support it)
- discreteevent 13y agoGood article. Explains exactly what pure mathematics is. My first love was physics so this is exactly the kind of mathematics I have no interest in. To me mathematics is just a language we can use to describe and understand nature. Its good that some of the brightest work on advancing that language but I'm more interested in the territory than the map.
- mathattack 13y agoI like the idea that pure math is pure problem solving, for it's own sake. This quote captures it nicely: It can be of no practical use to know that Pi is irrational, but if we can know, it surely would be intolerable not to know. But isn't this still somewhat practical? Proving things gives us a mental workout, even if there is not apparent use. (Not the pure mathematicians would say, "Yes, though it's still worth doing in the absence of this.")
- saraid216 13y agoAt that point, what isn't practical?