4 ms·
I find it sort of ironic for this sort of thing to show up on a computer programming site, because our world has long since discovered that automating itself be
by jerf 13y ago
I find it sort of ironic for this sort of thing to show up on a computer programming site, because our world has long since discovered that automating itself becomes a skill. Even if we hypothesize a world in which the top-level restaurants are fully automated behind the scenes, it will still be master chefs that come up with the new programs, new foods, new ways of doing things, and commanding dizzying new heights of pricing in the process.
The absolute worst case scenario is that the culinary world becomes like the visual arts or fashion worlds; the materials and general skills are broadly available, but there shall ever be an upper end of the art from which to sneer down at the plebians, even if it only in style and fashions, and by that I mean raw styles and fashions. The clothing fashion world shows this most clearly, in that creating knockoffs of today's fashions isn't even that technically challenging, and yet there is still a "high class" fashion world for those who care to participate in.
The instinctive human drive to differentiate is what creates that, the upper class attitude is what creates that, the incidental details of how one particular field happens to signal is hardly relevant, the actual details are themselves nearly infinitely malleable.
The programming world is so many levels deep into automation of automation of automation that we've nearly forgotten the promises that one day we'd be automated out of existence. But the promises were made, and they failed, because we merely upped our expectations and advanced to the next level. Perhaps someday there won't be a "next level" for us to rise to, but that is a world so different from ours we can no longer predict what it is like.
The culinary world will adapt. There will be much moaning, must wringing of hands, and a hell of a lot of signaling words flying around about how wonderful hand crafted artisan food is (even if for some reason, every day, fewer people act to consume it), even as there is ever and always still an elite, which will probably consist of mostly the same people anyhow.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sheetjs 13y agoThe restaurants in question are automating the parts of their business not directly related to their core competencies. They have their specialty dishes, and those are still made by hand.
- cookingrobot 13y agoI think about this a lot. There's something fundamentally lacking in the way we cook and share cooking, that other arts have already solved. When a musician creates music, they can record and share it with anyone who cares. Writers print books, actors make movies, coders make apps. With cooking, we're still stuck in the live performance era. In a restaurant you can eat what the chef prepares and enjoy their art. But if you can't get to the restaurant or can't afford it you miss out. Famous chefs release cookbooks and film cooking shows where they let you watch them and you can try to recreate their craft for yourself, but that's not really sharing the food. The problem is there is no food media. An actual dish can't be recorded, transmitted, and reproduced, and so we rely on storytelling about the food using other methods. Food is the subject but not the substance. We've been here before, and we've moved beyond this before. The mass media of writing started with monks transcribing text, but then was improved by the printing press. Writing let us describe music on sheets that you could reproduce by hand at home, but the media of music really started with the wax cylinder, then the phonograph and radio. I think food will become the next major art to become a medium.
- jaibot 13y agoI just bought some hot pockets.
- mcguire 13y ago"The problem is there is no food media. An actual dish can't be recorded, transmitted, and reproduced,..." Sure there is. There are likely plenty of copies of various dishes in the freezer section of your local grocery mart. Some are, objectively, pretty good; others are likely just much better than you could do yourself.
- lsc 13y ago>Sure there is. There are likely plenty of copies of various dishes in the freezer section of your local grocery mart. Some are, objectively, pretty good; others are likely just much better than you could do yourself. Huh. See? I am a /terrible/ cook. Like one out of three times I try to cook something it is objectively inedible. However... frozen foods? seriously? Please link me to some that are "pretty good" - I mean, I want to believe you, but I have tried many, and so far have been quite disappointed, both by the cheap and the expensive. Edit: When I say "frozen foods" I mean TV-dinner style fully-cooked food. I practically live off of frozen chicken... the uncooked kind that you throw in the oven.
- lsc 13y ago>The absolute worst case scenario is that the culinary world becomes like the visual arts or fashion worlds; the materials and general skills are broadly available, but there shall ever be an upper end of the art from which to sneer down at the plebians, even if it only in style and fashions, and by that I mean raw styles and fashions. The clothing fashion world shows this most clearly, in that creating knockoffs of today's fashions isn't even that technically challenging, and yet there is still a "high class" fashion world for those who care to participate in. huh. That seems like a pretty good scenario to me. I mean, the current state of clothing is... well, it's pretty great for the poor, and for people who don't want to spend a lot on clothing. And people who want to spend a lot of money on clothing seem to be happy, and people who want to pretend like they are spending a lot of money on clothing also seem to be happy, High-quality clothing that is in good repair but that is used and out of style is nearly free. so I really don't see the problem. My problem is that from what I've seen? when eating out, there's a very dramatic difference between what I get for $5 and what I get for $50. (or, more realistically, $20) Personally? I'm generally pretty pleased with pants that cost less than a nice meal. I mean, the difference between a pair of "Kirkland Signature" jeans and a pair of Diesel jeans is 10x in price, and as far as I can tell, functionally, the Kirkland jeans are just fine. In many ways better than the diesel jeans. Of course, I'm wearing jeans I bought at Costco, and that says things socially, but I'm pretty okay with that. They are good jeans. In fact, I've worn my costco jeans while eating $50 dinners. If I could walk into a McDonalds (or costco) and buy a $5 meal that was functionally equivalent (minus the social cache) to a $50 meal? I would be extremely happy, and I'd be happy to let the guy paying $50 for the same thing with nicer lighting feel superior to me.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]