6 ms·
Focus on Ocean’s Health as Dolphin Deaths Soar
- bbllee 13y agoA dead commenter said, "Any startup ideas on cleaning the Ocean? I guess no country wants to pay for this yet?" and I had two thoughts in response: There's a reason for the word "tragedy" in the phrase, "the tragedy of the commons"; "cleaning" probably isn't going to cut it; ocean warming and acidification will quite possibly cause mass extinctions.
- rosser 13y agoocean warming and acidification will quite possibly cause mass extinctions. There's no possibly about it. As soon as the oceans become too acidic for corals to form, whole ecosystems will collapse.
- Someone 13y agoBut will they become too acidic so fast that no coral can adapt? I know we are really good at changing the environment, but the oceans are huge.
- scarmig 13y agoThe oceans are huge, but we've already managed to decrease pH by 0.1 in the past century. A pessimistic but plausible scenario has ocean pH decreasing by an additional 0.7-0.8 by 2300. That's pretty fast. It's hard to predict how and how fast coral might adapt, but those are short time scales to expect evolution to act on.
- ble 13y agoPardon the profanity, but fuck! On a logarithmic scale, a decrease of 0.1 on the pH is a 25% increase in H+ concentration... ... and a decrease of 0.7 is a 500% increase in H+ concentration. That sounds apocalyptic, at least for ocean ecosystems. Warming and acidification are increasing jellyfish blooms, right? Do you know any good recipes for grilled jellyfish?
- jmpe 13y agoComplex question, but there are a few aspects that work against them: - coral typically takes several years before reaching sexual maturity. Adaptability to a changing environment strongly depends on this. - corals typically occupy ecological niches. - acidification directly interferes with a key part of their metabolism and habit. It's like asking whether mammals can't evolve to a life without skeletons. Corals are an extremely diverse group of organisms that interact with other organisms through complex relationships. Take them away (or reduce them to a select few species that fulfill a fitness) and you're going to see lots of damage to other populations.
- tolmasky 13y agoMaybe a better strategy is convincing one of these guys who seem more likely to be forward thinking: http://givingpledge.org http://givingpledge.org .
- bradleyjg 13y agoStill orders of magnitude off. Several billions of dollars can do many things but halting and reversing global climate change isn't one of them. If it's going to happen at all, which it probably won't, it'll take the coordinated effort of at least all the G-20 nations.
- ateevchopra 13y agoI guess UN should fund such people.
- hipaulgraham 13y agoLet's 'disrupt' this extinction event. Hacker News is grossly focused on exits and profits and money. Fuck money, let's save our dolphin friends. Have you no heart?
- Gravityloss 13y agoThe concept of laws were invented thousands of years ago to prevent just these tragedies. So we already have a solution. Now we only need to create such laws that pollution is greatly diminished. This will naturally lead to creation of lots of ecological niches for new startups, that will find the most efficient means to achieve these reductions. Naturally government funded long term research will also play a part in finding good solutions. The end customer will naturally pay for these changes. For example, it is cheaper to run transport ships with residue heavy fuel oil, the use of which has been banned almost everywhere else already. If we want to prevent that, we make laws that make it illegal. Then the ships will use some other, naturally more expensive fuel. The transport costs will go up and whatever you buy that was imported costs more, or whatever you export potentially pays less.
- ble 13y agoLaws are better at protecting individual rights and maintaining public order than protecting future generations from the unintended consequences of present and recent economic history.
- dredmorbius 13y agoThat's where custom, tradition, and taboo come to the fore. They're somewhat stronger in terms of social signalling over time than mere laws. Jared Diamond's Collapse explores this, both in positive aspects (Japan and several successful adaptations in Pacific Island and Borneo populations), as well as negative ones (Greenlander's insistence on raising cattle and not adopting Inuit practices).
- ble 13y agoI liked Collapse, but I really liked "The Collapse of Complex Societies." Written by an archaeologist, addresses many other scholars' theories of collapse, and provides an excellent economics / complexity argument. http://www.amazon.com/Collapse-Complex-Societies-Studies-Archaeology/dp/052138673X http://www.amazon.com/Collapse-Complex-Societies-Studies-Arc... (not an affiliate link) Also, the idea of "diminishing marginal returns on added complexity" suggests a lot about why maintenance, extension, and management of software systems becomes harder over time.
- RyanMcGreal 13y ago> There's a reason for the word "tragedy" in the phrase, "the tragedy of the commons" Small but important clarification: as Garrett Hardin later said, he should have called it the tragedy of the unregulated commons. The problem is not the fact that the ocean doesn't have a private owner but rather that the legal framework does not presently cover its responsible access and use.
- ble 13y agoTrue, so let's be even more exact: "presently" is the wrong tense; present acidification and warming are consequences of actions taken over the last several decades.
- shootaray 13y agoAny startup ideas on cleaning the Ocean? I guess no country wants to pay for this yet?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bradL 13y agoWe are probably living in one of Earth's great mass extinctions. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- arethuza 13y agoIs Fukushima really worse than the decades of nuclear weapons testing carried out by the US, France and the UK in the Pacific?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- arethuza 13y agoAnd I have no idea whether Fukushima is actually worse or not - I was trying to ask a genuine question, not be snarky. :-)
- gaius 13y agoThere are two factors there really, the nuclear stuff, and the material that was swept out to sea from the surrounding area which would have happened whether or not the reactor was there.
- epaladin 13y agoI wish there was a way to know what the actual condition of Fukushima is. News reports have been so conflicting, it seems the only way to know what's going on would be to go and measure things yourself.
- amalag 13y agoFukushima would be like decades of dirty nuclear bomb testing.
- Someone 13y agoThe way I interpret this is that we simply don't know what causes these extinctions. It could well be that they are perfectly normal in the sense that one gets them about every X years. A bad year for dolphin food, possibly in combination with a harsh winter may make large parts of the population get susceptible to a disease that they normally don't suffer much from. Predator-prey systems are known to show highly erratic behavior (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lotka–Volterra_equation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lotka–Volterra_equation gives the idealized version for only two species. That is tractable, but discrete multi-species ones aren't) This _could_ just be an example of such behaviour, but there could also be a human-induced change that changes that system to one where we end up with zero fish and, a few years later, zero dolphins. Or, possibly, the system has been on a course of a catastrophic event for thousands of years.
- 3am 13y agoYour interpretation doesn't bear any particular resemblance to the article. There's no mention in it of any prey shortages, nor anything about extinction. They do mention several times that they don't know precise why this morbillivirus outbreak is occurring now, though. But that "The Indian River Lagoon, a diverse estuary, has been tainted by huge algae blooms caused in part by too much nitrogen. Research on some of the dead dolphins in the estuary — 76 died this year, the third series of deaths since 2001 — has showed that some had high levels of mercury, fungal diseases, antibiotic-resistant bacteria and oral-genital tumors. The dolphins found were emaciated." and in some other cases, they have a pretty decent idea, but it's unconfirmed: "Gulf Coast states and the federal government are still investigating the impact of the oil spill in the region, and scientists cannot yet say why the dolphins are dying. So far, it appears that toxins or morbillivirus are not the primary cause. “We can’t conclusively say what role oil played at this time,” Ms. Fougeres said. “But the event is pretty unprecedented in terms of how long the die-off has been occurring and how many have died as part of that event.” A NOAA study released last week of 29 bottlenose dolphins that were examined in Barataria Bay in Louisiana — an area hit hard by the spill — found that they had lung disease, hormonal abnormalities and other illnesses that are consistent with exposure to oil."
- 13y ago
- pond_lilly 13y agoas usual the public is given only one side of the story. No one mentions the fact that this die off happens exclusively in Navy testing areas like FL, Virginia, etc. No journalist bothered to dig deeper and learn a thing or two about morbillivirus. Morbillivirus is a convenient scapegoat because it is naturally present in wild populations. In fact there have been several studies documenting virus presence in wild dolphins without any die offs. It is like herpes in humans. Additionally, no one mentions that die off includes offshore species like humpback, pygmy sperm whales, common dolphins that not only do not mingle with coastal bottlenose dolphins, but rarely mingle with each other. Kogias (pygmy sperm whales) are solitary cetaceans and do not come in close contact with anyone to get a virus that needs proximity to get infection. This whole thing is one giant cover-up for the Navy as they are the ones causing this. It will continue, as they just got awarded another permit to decimate marine life for next 5 years. There is a severe ecocide going on out there, and virus gets the blame. EDIT: WE have been tracking strandings worldwide and can say that many whales and dolphins deaths are caused by human activities like Big Oil explorations and Navy exercises and tests. What is worse, the new field of deep sea mining will pose even more danger to marine life. We can use any help we can get, if someone wants to help us, please get in touch with me.
- pilooch 13y agoSince they were supposed to be the first to leave Earth, this sounds like another bad signal for us...
- pilooch 13y agoSince they were supposed to be the first to leave Earth, this sounds like another bad signal for us...