4 ms·
The government stated that they have filters which will make it so that no one would see any information other than what is requested. The judge stated that tha
by dalke 13y ago
The government stated that they have filters which will make it so that no one would see any information other than what is requested. The judge stated that that was reasonable.
Using your analogy, the government wanted to "grep '^target_name$' phone_book.txt", so while software did see all 400k phone numbers, the government did not.
I happen to disagree with the court on this, but I think your analogy isn't useful as to understand why. Instead, there should be a balancing of cost vs. impact.
Levinson/Lavasoft stated that they would provide that pen register information for a development fee of some $2,000-$3,500. (Note: Verizon's price list says they charge about $700 for access to that data.)
The government refused to pay, saying that they were not aware of paying anyone else for pen trap data.
So the first question is, how much non-revenue generating work can a company be forced to do in order to respond to a pen register request? Obviously the answer has to be non-zero in order for the law to be meaningful, but it can't drive a company out of business.
The government points out that a cheap solution, which bypasses the internal architecture, is for the company to provide access to all of the data, and use filters to remove all non-relevant data.
The secondary question is, where does the boundary sit? Is it at the company/filter layer, where the company is force to release all records to the filter, or with the filter/human investigator layer, where the humans only see the relevant data?
Personally, I put it on the company/filter layer. The government and the court disagree with me. Their view is that you can trust the filter to do what it says it does. (When Levinson asked for oversight or audit of the filter, the judge denied the request.)
However, in the case of a "grep ... phonebook", where the filter program can be audited, and run with oversight from both sides, then I find the request to be more reasonable.
- MWil 13y agoAs far as the law goes, there should always be disclaimers that metaphors and analogies are sometimes useful but only get you so far. Especially when it comes to technology, they almost never hold water and look silly years down the line when the technology is better understood by the general population. I don't have the necessary education or knowledge to make a better analogy so for that I apologize. EDIT: Oh, I am a lawyer. I was just noting that in law school (and internet law especially) you have to be wary of judges/parties using analogies in their arguments b/c they are almost always imperfect in one way or another
- dalke 13y agoHave you skimmed through the PDF? I've found that even though I don't have any legal training, it's usually pretty easy to read at least the transcripts. Do that a few times, and things start to make some sense. I've found court judgements are often quite easy to understand, if you don't mind skipping a lot of citation references. For example, Computer Associates v. Altai helped me understand the abstraction-filtration-comparison test as applied to copyright of software.
- MWil 13y agosee my edit above, I did more than just skim, I did a pretty thorough initial reading as you can see from my comments here
- dalke 13y agoIndeed you have! I find it difficult to track account names, especially unfamiliar ones, and didn't note that I had even commented elsewhere on your threads of doing that reading. (For example, it wasn't until 7th grade that I noticed that various books that I really liked were all written by the same author, so I should get more books by that author.)
- malandrew 13y agoIt would be interesting, if, when replying, other comments by the person on the same HN post were available.
- devicenull 13y ago> Levinson/Lavasoft stated that they would provide that pen register information for a development fee of some $2,000-$3,500. (Note: Verizon's price list says they charge about $700 for access to that data.) plus > The government refused to pay, saying that they were not aware of paying anyone else for pen trap data So the government is not aware of paying anyone, despite Verizon having a (semi)public price list?
- dalke 13y agoI had the same thought. But note that one is a development fee and the other is a service fee.
- malandrew 13y agoAnd one involves a developer who is likely of a much higher technical ability. Given his technical ability, Levinson's hourly rate is probably several times higher than the rate for the Verizon employee that would be assigned to do the work. It's not like a manager would authorize putting their best and brightest to do work that does not generate revenue.
- dalke 13y agoI take it you didn't read the PDF? Levinson also gave a time estimate of "between 20 to 40 hours" (p114), which works out to $40 to $80 per hour. Let's call it $50 for the ease of comparison. This is an entirely reasonable hourly fee. Verizon quoted a $50 court processing fee, which almost certainly takes less than 1 hour to do. It charges a $50 activation fee, which can't reasonably take 1 hour, and $10/day pen tap fee, and I doubt a Verizon employee is spending more than 12 minutes per day per pen tap. In other words, those documents show that Verizon is almost certainly charging more per unit time than Lavasoft would, and definitely not "several times" lower than Levinson.
- malandrew 13y agoNo I did not. This PDF and the White House NSA recommendations I have on my todo list for after the 25th of the month. Unfortunately, right now I cannot find the time to read anything this long. That being said, thanks for the clarification and specific relevant facts from the PDF.
- malandrew 13y agoI would imagine that some sort of pair programming recorded session, where either side can pause the session and argue against what the other side would like to do next and why they believe it to be inappropriate.