8 ms·
Even fine restaurants serve coffee made with capsules
- sanoli 13y agotl;dr: Huge number of fine restaurants serve Nespresso-capsule coffee. They are more consistent than barista-made coffee; the whole process is controlled, and even came out ahead in blind tests. Author however still argues that there is a place for the artisan and the handmade. Author didn't give the win to Nespresso on the blind test -- yet author actually saw which coffee was in each cup. Author actually rendered rendered his score in said blind test useless.
- wila 13y agoYou forgot to mention that author based his article around a test with 4 subjects. Eg. statistic results based on a sample size of 4. I think we do not even have to debate the quality of the coffee used in the tests and that the coffee the author brought from home was ground 4 days earlier.
- devindotcom 13y agoSure, the coffee is fine. The question is one of control for me, not of quality. I like old-school "analog" coffee like my simple pourover or stovetop espresso machine because they are simple devices and, properly maintained, will make coffee forever. A capsule coffee machine is complex, the capsules can't be made by you (and some are triple-packaged, leading to lots of waste), they require power and microprocessors, and so on. I choose the simpler method not because the coffee is better (though I'm sure it can be, and many factors are at play here), but because, in a way, it's the FOSS alternative to the bloated, proprietary capsule systems.
- sitharus 13y agoAt home I have a NZ$150 single-boiler espresso machine and a $80 conical burr grinder. I buy 50g bags of coffee for $10 from the local coffee roaster, which works out to around $0.50 per coffee, around half the price of the nespresso pods. It all works rather well.
- jmackinn 13y agoSorry, did you say you pay $10 for a 50g bag of coffee?
- monkeyspaw 13y agoMust be a typo. Can't get 20 coffees from 50g. My guess would be that it should be 500g.
- ams6110 13y agoI love my Aeropress. Simple, elegant, foolproof. The only way I can think of to make it better would be if it were made of pyrex instead of plastic.
- fuzzix 13y agoIME, depending on your grind, it can take quite a bit of pressure to plunge the aeropress. Having sustained a cut (well, more a chunk gouged out) from a broken pyrex cup, I think I'll stick with the plastic.
- enra 13y agoOrdering coffee or tea in a restaurant is most of the time disappointing anyway. Doesnt matter how fine or average the place is, they seen to use some bulk coffee usually prepared with an industrial coffee maker (drip coffee, not espresso drinks). Restaurants take great care of lot other food and beverage details by for some reason they cant use decent fresh coffee or tea.
- plorkyeran 13y agoEven if Nespresso was significantly worse than it is, I wouldn't be surprised by an otherwise good restaurant using it, simply because I don't expect good food to correlate to good coffee. Getting coffee or tea that's any better than merely drinkable is quite uncommon in my experience regardless of the quality of the food. I assume it's different in countries where some espresso after (or before) a meal is more common, though.
- djur 13y agoI would expect even good restaurants to have just okay coffee, not as good as the average cafe, unless we're talking an excellent breakfast place. In the US, people have coffee with breakfast and with dessert. So a dinner restaurant isn't going to serve a lot of cups of coffee -- just to a subset of people who choose to have dessert. And although good coffee is always welcome, you don't really need a great coffee with dessert, just a decent one. You want something to perk your senses up a bit after the meal and to provide heat and bitterness to balance out the sweet, probably cold dessert. Nobody's going to be focusing on the coffee, just the dessert. And people don't expect to pay more than a few bucks for a cup of coffee, even at a nice place. So there's really not much profit in stocking great coffee, installing top-of-the-line coffee machines, and training your staff how to make it. Making espresso is relatively time-consuming, too, as is grinding the beans and cleaning everything (working as a barista is like 90% cleaning). So you buy something that sounds impressive enough to list on the menu for as cheap as you can get it, you grind up enough ahead of time to get you through the night, you put it in a big industrial-sized drip machine with an insulated carafe, and you forget about it.
- toyg 13y ago>Nobody's going to be focusing on the coffee, just the dessert. I think that's actually a common misconception. Maybe it's relevant only in coffee-heavy cultures, but a coffee is (often) the very last thing one will taste before leaving the restaurant. You want your customers to leave on a high note, right? This is why so much effort is spent on the dessert, the final dish. But the coffee will follow the dessert! That's the final dish. When an otherwise decent meal is followed by a terrible coffee, to me it's depressing; it forces me to re-evaluate the experience. Maybe those dishes weren't as good as I thought, maybe they got them right by accident... This is why many restaurants will actually offer you liquor at the very end; it's an easy way to make you leave happy. If you don't go down that route, then you should invest some time in making sure the coffee is good. Or at least get a Nespresso :)
- badman_ting 13y agoThere is a lot going on here. All I can say is that I'm not sure El Bulli is a good example of the human touch being lost. The amount of manpower that went into their meals was insane. I'm sure Adria said something about functioning like machines, but in the event that meant huge amounts of practice, crazy attention to detail, tons of trial and error, endless painstaking documentation, etc. Hard work, but creative work. Watch "Cooking in Progress" if you're interested in the details (a bit dry in my opinion).
- kunai 13y agoThe Nespresso story brings up an important point, especially for everybody in Silicon Valley. Analog. No, really, I'm serious. It really is about analog. For years and years, everyone who has had any experience with technology has been striving to create perfection and flawless beauty in every sense of the words. Digital is the best way to do this – it's calculated, cold, and mathematical. It's predictable and reassuring. But humans aren't digital. Our hands tremble; they don't stay steady like a robot's mechanical arm. Our brains aren't perfect: they often forget things we want to remember, and remember things we want to forget. Our walking isn't straight. Many of us have less-than-flawless health and vision. We're not completely symmetrical, and look pretty ugly without clothing. In other words, humans are imperfect. But, perfection, while it is the antithesis to imperfection, is paradoxically horrible for humans. Our brains are wired to expect change and differentiation from the routine. We like good surprises, and monotony gets dull. Unlike a computer, our neurons are always firing and active rather than passive, so we hate passivity. So, isn't perfection just the antithesis of everything that makes the world beautiful? A lovely red leaf hanging on a tree long after the winter solstice. The knotted wood on a piano. The fingerprints on a record. Isn't perfection what takes the life out of life? As we continue to automate, we really, seriously need to ask ourselves a question: will we accept convenience for mediocrity? Sadly, consumer choices and corporate brainwashing have shown in the past that we will. And that won't change in the future. Enjoy your handmade coffee now, because it will get rarer and rarer in the future. And with every imperfect barista replaced with a perfect machine, we'll lose a little bit of what makes humans... ...humans.
- nitrogen 13y agoAlthough your description of human imperfection is picturesque and I tend to agree, I don't doubt that we can automate imperfection. I've given the subject some thought recently since I just spent all of yesterday manually tweaking note start and end times in a sequenced piano composition of mine to make it sound more natural.
- flogic 13y agoI would argue instead that digital "perfection" allows us to enjoy variety better. Take this example. The coffee isn't the centerpeice of the experience. When going to a restraunt the primary points are generally the people you go with and the food. In that regard, substandard coffee would do more harm than good.
- heydenberk 13y agoThis is much more true in Europe than in the United States. Many trendy restaurants in the US are actually getting less automatic by doing pour over coffee at the table or otherwise in view of the diners.
- adamconroy 13y agoI don't see an issue. The capsule coffee should be just as good and if its a time saver then why wouldn't a business use them. Personally I don't use a capsule machine because I don't want my coffee choices limited by manufacturer. Also, instead of 25c per cup, capsules are 80-90c per cup.
- yawz 13y agoI think people underestimate the importance of "consistency"! As a coffee lover I value consistency a lot. Nespresso may not be "the best" coffee but it offers a great taste/cost/practicality value.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jerf 13y agoI find it sort of ironic for this sort of thing to show up on a computer programming site, because our world has long since discovered that automating itself becomes a skill. Even if we hypothesize a world in which the top-level restaurants are fully automated behind the scenes, it will still be master chefs that come up with the new programs, new foods, new ways of doing things, and commanding dizzying new heights of pricing in the process. The absolute worst case scenario is that the culinary world becomes like the visual arts or fashion worlds; the materials and general skills are broadly available, but there shall ever be an upper end of the art from which to sneer down at the plebians, even if it only in style and fashions, and by that I mean raw styles and fashions. The clothing fashion world shows this most clearly, in that creating knockoffs of today's fashions isn't even that technically challenging, and yet there is still a "high class" fashion world for those who care to participate in. The instinctive human drive to differentiate is what creates that, the upper class attitude is what creates that, the incidental details of how one particular field happens to signal is hardly relevant, the actual details are themselves nearly infinitely malleable. The programming world is so many levels deep into automation of automation of automation that we've nearly forgotten the promises that one day we'd be automated out of existence. But the promises were made, and they failed, because we merely upped our expectations and advanced to the next level. Perhaps someday there won't be a "next level" for us to rise to, but that is a world so different from ours we can no longer predict what it is like. The culinary world will adapt. There will be much moaning, must wringing of hands, and a hell of a lot of signaling words flying around about how wonderful hand crafted artisan food is (even if for some reason, every day, fewer people act to consume it), even as there is ever and always still an elite, which will probably consist of mostly the same people anyhow.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sheetjs 13y agoThe restaurants in question are automating the parts of their business not directly related to their core competencies. They have their specialty dishes, and those are still made by hand.
- cookingrobot 13y ago
- RuCrazy 13y agohow does this story pertain to hacker news....come again!?
- holograham 13y agocoffee always pertains to Hacker News...it's Hacker fuel!
- toyg 13y agoAutomation vs "handmade" is a very important topic for our geek world, and very broad. This article signals that, even in something as human as making coffee, automation is clearly winning. And yet the author refuses to concede the point (I'd do the same, although for different reasons). It's important for anyone involved in creative industries to understand, in their specific field, what can be automated today, what has already been automated, and what should not be automated. These are huge factors that will affect your training, your output, your pricing, your marketing and your future strategy, regardless of which field of endeavour you're in.
- toyg 13y agoI'm not surprised. As a coffee-drinking Italian, I personally think Nespresso is really good at what it does: it delivers, time after time, a great coffee with no effort whatsoever. You'll have to find a really good barista using really good equipment and really good coffee to beat it. It's the pinnacle of decades of evolutionary experiments from one of the richest companies on Earth, fine-tuning what is, like the article says, a relatively simple process; when you look at it that way, it's not surprising that it works so well. This said, their business model is very much anti-consumer: they're doing with coffee what HP and Epson did with ink. For this reason alone, I never bought a Nespresso and I'll stick to brewing my own coffee. As the article says, it's not just about measuring, not even measuring quality: it's about the kind of world we want to build.
- fennecfoxen 13y agoNespresso machines also can't make pretty latte art... though I don't know whether that's legit-Italian or just third-wave-American :)
- unlikelymordant 13y agooh really? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IDQ1cR-FvJ0 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IDQ1cR-FvJ0 Though much better printers exist, the video shows the concept.
- rubiquity 13y agoYou lost me at latte and then killed me at Latte art. Coffee bombed with milk isn't coffee.
- voltagex_ 13y agoNo, it's coffee with milk in it. I am a coffee-snob. In some ways this is a curse - I hate nearly all the coffee available to me locally. Latte art or no, there are particular tastes I can't stand anymore, where when I first started drinking coffee I wouldn't have cared if the coffee was Nescafe or single-origin.
- 13y ago
- dreamfactory 13y agoThis is a bit ridiculous. Nespresso is best described as not bad and not good - it's drinkable in the same way as Starbucks. The technology is pretty rudimentary and the machines don't have sufficient boilers to get a consistent water temperature going through the coffee (tightly controlled water temperature and freshness of the coffee are the two main variables for flavour). The espresso they made in the test must have been pretty mediocre not to trounce Nespresso. (The author's coffee was never going to win any prizes - wrong beans, wrong grind, and 4 days old - a decent brew needs beans ground within minutes at worst).
- saryant 13y agoThat's not quite true. Most beans should be given at least 24 hours rest after roast. Many African varietals need 48. That's the time it takes for CO2 in the beans to degas.
- dreamfactory 13y agoI don't mean after roast (whole beans should be good for a couple of weeks). The author had ground his beans 4 days previous to the test.
- Schwolop 13y agoI stopped reading the article after he admitted that part. What a waste of a setup to ruin the experiment with a completely pointless test.
- saryant 13y agoAh, you're right. I read too fast.
- stephen_g 13y agoI usually try to use my beans within two weeks (and after around four days resting period) after roasting. But we have pretty bad humidity here so maybe you could keep it longer elsewhere. As for after grinding - you can't really expect it to produce a decent extraction even _ten minutes_ after grinding.
- kimonos 13y agoI really agree on this: "Humans are imperfect, and so a world of perfection that denies the human element can never be truly perfect after all.".. Nice post!
- cpt1138 13y agoI found this app called Acceptable Espresso. A bunch of coffee nuts in SF go around and test only espresso and if its consistently "acceptable" they put it in the app. I have tried a bunch of what they deem acceptable and its some of the best espresso I have had in the world. Now to me there are several aspects to this. One clear factor is whether the barista "cares" about the coffee they are giving me. Clay at Special X-tra is so damn good at pulling a perfect shot every single time and Chris just doesn't care and pulls a mediocre shot at best. Everywhere I go where the barista "cares" about pulling that shot the espresso is "acceptable." I don't judge on characteristics of the beans/roast, I know some like acid, some like smooth. If the coffee is fresh, not burned, ground properly, tamped properly (an artform) and pulled properly and with care, I am going to like it most likely. In terms of the Nespresso system, what you've done is remove the possibility of someone caring about the coffee they are serving me. I've tried espresso's from the Nespresso system and they are not even close to what I can get at Elite Audio, Special Xtra (make sure Clay does it), Vega, Blue Bottle (more of scene than I usually like), Cento, or Jackson Place. Its reliably very mediocre at best. The least acceptable espresso I've had is at Coffee Bar, where they roast a little too dark for my tastes, and even those, as long as I tell them to pull it short, are much better than a Nespresso system shot.
- Goopplesoft 13y ago"Caring" doesn't mean much in the context of a blind coffee taste test, nor does it mean much in the context of good things. Caring to make something good and having the ability to do so are completely separate things.
- Groxx 13y agoPeople who care tend to improve, though.
- dasil003 13y agoYes, however it's not a completely bogus indicator since pulling a good shot is probably difficult to perfect if you don't care, and if you do care probably not so hard that you can't learn to do it reasonably properly and consistently.
- jcrites 13y agoThe discussion about whether products are better when made by an artisan reminds me of the essay called "What Colour are your bits?" http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/lawpoli/colour/2004061001.php http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/lawpoli/colour/2004061001.php The article discusses how society treats information differently depending on where it came from, and how it was produced -- even if that difference is not observable in the raw bits themselves. When we are discussing whether artisan-made products are better, I think it is worthwhile to have in mind whether we're considering objective, measurable standards, or a different sort of perspective that takes into account "color". From the article: > Of course, we need to think about yield, efficiency and environmental impact. But we also need to think about what kind of world we want to live in. And if we do, most of us would say that we would prefer food chains that preserve human links between consumer, farmer, land, and animals, in a landscape that combines functionality and beauty as much as is possible. Is the concept of "preserving human links" something that can be measured objectively, or is it color?
- lesinski 13y agoIn order to pack coffee into air-tight pods like Nespresso does, the coffee must first completely degas and become stale. What fine restaurant would serve a stale dish? Regardless of consistency, taste, automation, etc?
- andrewcooke 13y agotechnically, how can they make ground coffee in a pod comparable to freshly ground coffee? even if you use an inert gas in the pod, aren't you going to have chemical changes in the pod? and some loss (evaporation) of lighter chemicals? it seems like if grinding freshly is important (and i have heard many times that it is), then it's just not physically possible to reproduce the taste via a pre-ground pod. odd.
- dreamfactory 13y agoThe gas works well at preserving the coffee from oxidation. The bigger problem is with water temperature - espresso is incredibly sensitive and will become either sour or bitter if the temperature goes outside a very narrow band. This is what you are spending money on with expensive espresso machines - PID temperature controls and lots of heavy brass parts to maintain an even heat. Nespresso machines are pretty cheap and plastic and I believe they use specially made bland coffee blends to disguise this. Frankly you are better off with French press or pourover at home.
- damoe 13y agoChess enthusiasts recently enjoyed two humans play in the World Chess Championship even though the machine has conquered chess. I see no reason that coffee lovers need give up the barista. I have a Nespresso and have made my own Sous Vide cooker, but I'll throw stakes on the BBQ at most dinner parties because of the social aspects.
- anigbrowl 13y agoSadly, coffee capsules are about the most wasteful way imaginable to get your caffeine fix, to the point that the inventor of the technology now says he's sorry he came up with it: http://www.eastbayexpress.com/oakland/waste-the-dark-side-of-the-new-coffee-craze/Content?oid=3687220&showFullText=true http://www.eastbayexpress.com/oakland/waste-the-dark-side-of...
- stephen_g 13y agoI'm a bit confused at what this article is trying to prove. I live in Australia, which surprisingly has some of the best coffee culture in the world, but here you sort of just expect that all restaurants serve pretty crap coffee. I would never, ever use it as a benchmark for good coffee... In my city (third largest in the country), we have hundreds of little cafes that either roast on-site or are supplied by local artesian roasters. The quality of the product that many of these places are producing is pretty incredible (to my taste at least), and I have never had a capsule coffee that comes close...
- code_duck 13y agoThe real content of the article comes in the second half, after the coffee discussion is over. I am tempted to comment on the coffee content as well, though.
- hyp0 13y agoMy experience: I've tried nespresso and it's just not in the same league as really excellent coffee. This is true for some surprising reasons. Coffee from most specialist espresso cafes is really not that good. But some are. I got the barista at one to teach me how she made coffee (Note: although already experienced, she wasn't very good for the first year at that cafe, but became extraordinary within 3 years). The two things I learned were that (1). the grind is affected by the changing humidity and temperature of the day, so must be adjusted (this is more important for an espresso cafe, where the machine is near the entrance - in a fancy hotel, it would be climate controlled); (2). the texture of the milk froth (for a latte) is very important to the experience - when correct, you can see the milk falling like snow through the coffee. There is no boundary between coffee and milk, but a very gradual gradient (which disappears within a few minutes). Although it looks nice, the big difference is in the incredible silky taste. tl;dr grind and frothing automation
- ojii 13y agomy experience is that if you're going for good, not excellent, coffee nespresso is damn good. especially if you factor in time and effort.
- jzzskijj 13y agoI realize the competition wasn't the main point of the article, but: "In distant last place came the ground coffee I had brought, a very good quality, single-estate bean, but not roasted for espresso and ground four days earlier, a little too coarsely for Bruno’s machine." Bringing not roasted for espresso coffee to espresso competition makes me wonder what was the purpose of the competition. Why not to bring something that had the characteristics of a winning coffee.
- shiven 13y agoGreat to hear I drink the same coffee everyday that is served by Michelin starred restaurants. Viva la Nespresso!