3 ms·
I'm surprised, in an industry that is founded upon automating repetitive tasks, that the coding interview can't be automated. Isn't that what standardized testi
by analog31 13y ago
I'm surprised, in an industry that is founded upon automating repetitive tasks, that the coding interview can't be automated. Isn't that what standardized testing is all about?
- ColinWright 13y agoThis comment nails it: > I really don't find these questions to be useful indicators > of the things that make-up a good software engineer. I am > using "software engineer" here on purpose and as something > distinct from "programmer" or "coder". > One will design and develop good reliable products that are > maintainable and extensible. The other will just crank out > code and is likely to not really add value beyond that. > I want to know how a person thinks and reasons, how good he > or she is about data representation or the formulation and > communication of a strategy in creating a solution. I want > to know how a person thinks at the abstract, code, project > and product levels. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6942548 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6942548 Standardized testing will quickly get subverted, with people "studying for the test." It's almost a theorem that any proxy for assessment will become subverted, with people passing the test without actually possessing the necessary underlying skill. In math people keep complaining about "teaching to the test" and that people pass the tests, and yet don't have the skills. Same will happen if you try to standardize computer recruitment.
- analog31 13y agoVery good point, and I realize that I was being a bit sarcastic about standardized testing. In fact it's possible that if a particular set of coding questions gains widespread use, then it will function as a de facto standardized test, with the result that you predict. This could already be the case if both employers and applicants are searching online for lists of the best interview questions.
- vonmoltke 13y agoStandardized testing will quickly get subverted, with people "studying for the test." It's almost a theorem that any proxy for assessment will become subverted, with people passing the test without actually possessing the necessary underlying skill. In math people keep complaining about "teaching to the test" and that people pass the tests, and yet don't have the skills. Same will happen if you try to standardize computer recruitment. Hasn't the industry effectively done that already? Doesn't the fact that almost anyone of reasonable ability[1] can pass an interview after studying something like Cracking the Code Interview indicate that you can successfully "study for the test"? [1] I am assuming that, even when "teaching to the test", a certain amount of baseline ability is still required to actually pass.
- analog31 13y agoHere's my observation about "teaching to the test," having two kids who are now in middle school. Since every kid has to pass, the test is written to the lowest common denominator. Drilling the test over and over, to boost the school's average by a few points, short-changes the kids who have already mastered the material and need more challenge. Something like "cracking the code interview" could become an upper bound.