3 ms·
That's all nice if you live somewhere where rentals and mortgages are even. Do those even exist? Where I live renters pay a $300-500/mo premium over what they
by busterarm 13y ago
That's all nice if you live somewhere where rentals and mortgages are even. Do those even exist?
Where I live renters pay a $300-500/mo premium over what they'd pay if they had a mortgage.
I sure would like an extra $6000 a year to go to building my wealth vs building someone else's, wouldn't you?
Edit: That money is almost pure profit here as well, because the homeowners here don't put any money into upkeep and most don't even pay their PoA/HoA fees as most of those are bankrupt here and having a hard time collecting from anyone.
- mjmahone17 13y agoWhere I'm from (not where I live), renters pay about $300-500/mo less than the cost of a mortgage.
- busterarm 13y agoYeah, renting in a lot of places is a good deal. A lot of real estate markets (read: NY & SF) are totally insane. A lot of wealthy people (corporations are people too now. The courts said so!) are sitting on limited space and expecting outrageous ROIs out of their land (that goes for rentals too). But they're never even, and that's the point. I don't want to get on my LVT preacher's box, but man would I be pleased to see that happen.
- patrickk 13y ago> Where I live renters pay a $300-500/mo premium over what they'd pay if they had a mortgage. >I sure would like an extra $6000 a year to go to building my wealth vs building someone else's That's the crux of the argument here. Money that would otherwise be spread around (the difference between owning and renting) instead lines the pockets of the shareholders of private equity firms. It's almost like a forced tax, because if you have to live in an area (e.g. can't move because of family, employment, access to schools etc), but are outbidded from the house you'd otherwise be able to afford - that means you are forced to rent.
- busterarm 13y agoExactly, I was just driving it home. ;) In my situation I don't mind it right now. It's a lot cheaper than living in New York and I work remotely. There's absolutely no decent work here, so I don't want to be trapped owning a home down here. Unfortunately, I'm starting to realize that with my increased travel costs, living in New York would still work out better for me financially and (more importantly) socially.
- raverbashing 13y ago> Where I live renters pay a $300-500/mo premium over what they'd pay if they had a mortgage. Today. Tomorrow it may change. (Where is this, by the way?) Rents follow the revenue more closely. A mortgage is fixed. Rents also give you much more flexibility. If it's too expensive you can move somewhere else. Just ask those who tried to sell their houses to pay the mortgage but who were still short.
- busterarm 13y agoJust outside Hilton Head Island. The best part is that this area has been growing significantly for ~20 years now and is only going to get bigger in the next 10. Values are steadily climbing. Homeowners here are making an absolute killing doing almost nothing to maintain their property. Folks who've lived here a while are getting rich.
- minimax 13y agoA mortgage is fixed. My understanding is that long term fixed rate mortgages are a USA thing. I don't think such a thing as 30 year fixed rate mortgage exists in Europe, for instance.
- busterarm 13y agoI think you're right. My friend has been keeping me in the loop of his process of buying an apartment in Copenhagen (okay, Amager). When he explained the deal to me, I was thinking "oh my gosh, that's crazy, I would never want to do it that way" but every year he meets with the lending bank and refinance in both their and his favor every time. It's worked out to be a pretty good deal for him so far.
- raverbashing 13y agoI think you're correct And in some places there are 'fixed' mortgages that have some form of inflation adjustment
- waps 13y agoIt certainly exists, it's just not that affordable.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- zimbu668 13y agoIt's not quite that simple. We owned a house in Baltimore for 8 years, when we sold we got $3000 more than we had paid for it. Additionally we had done ~$40,000 worth of work that a renter would not have. Add in $7500 in commission when we sold. If I can still do basic math, that's an extra $463.54 per month to be a home owner. Maybe we should have rented after all.
- busterarm 13y agoI know this, but it's not that simple either. Long term renters do put work/money into their apartments. My mom has put probably twice that into the NY apartment she's been renting since 1970. She did work that the landlord was unwilling to do or do quickly (we were repeatedly flooded out by our hoarder upstairs neighbor in the '90s and the landlord dragged their feet on repairs because they wanted a rent controlled tenant out). When you say you put $40k in work into your house and got $3k more than you paid for it, are you saying that you got $43k over your purchase price? If not I think we need to take another look at your accounting process here: a) the $40k is optional and b) if I'm right about your math, a bad investment. Not trying to be rude. If it comes off that way, sorry.
- zimbu668 13y agoNo, we got $3000 over our purchase price. a) Yes the $40K was optional, but we probably would have had to sell for $20k less had we not done the work. Bringing our "ownership tax" to ~$275 a month. Pretty close to the lower end rent premium you mentioned above. b) It was absolutely a bad investment in straight financial terms. We did get the pleasure of a nicer house, for what it's worth. Also not trying to be rude :)
- clavalle 13y agoSo, compared to what you would pay for rent, were you able to recoup any of the stored value you paid over the years? Compared to losing 100% of what you would pay for shelter every month, how did what you end up with compare? Not as an investment, but as a value store?