3 ms·
This is mostly an issue of the limitations of law, or to put it more precisely, having to deal with the letter of the law versus the spirit of the law. If the
by belorn 13y ago
This is mostly an issue of the limitations of law, or to put it more precisely, having to deal with the letter of the law versus the spirit of the law.
If the intention is only to prevent large-scale data center, forbidding all commercial form of servers is clearly overkill by a large margin. However, if they limit the scope, they might miss use cases which are by everyone's definition abusive, but not technically a "large-scale data center".
I find the same problem in license texts. The GPL should really only have to be a single line saying "Do what ever you want with the program, so long you do not restrict anyone else in doing the same". Following the spirit, it would cover any form of restrictions now and in the future, regardless if people tried to use hardware restrictions, legal restriction, or obfuscation (like machine language) to restrict users of the program. Applying a different license with a lower requirement, would simply be a matter of intentionally trying to circumvent the wishes of the author.
Alas, licenses are not written like if they were enforced by the spirit of the text, but rather as if they were enforced by the letter of the text. As such, they try to include all forms of license circumventing into a now rather long license text, and when new license-circumventing techniques gets invented, the license text gets an update.
Wouldn't it be nice if licenses and terms of services would just write down what they want, rather than trying to cover every aspect imaginable just in case?
- al2o3cr 13y agoMuch like computers, the modern legal system doesn't work particularly well if you expect it to "do what I mean, not what I said". The difference is that compiler errors on the computer don't usually cost six figures when they happen. ;)