5 ms·
There is no reason why a government cannot provide good public services from a reasonable tax rate, and also avoid corporatism and regulatory capture. Yes, the
by pdonis 13y ago
There is no reason why a government cannot provide good public services from a reasonable tax rate, and also avoid corporatism and regulatory capture.
Yes, there is: governments are run by people, subject to the same incentives as people in any other part of society, including the perverse and misaligned incentives that cause "market failures" in other parts of society.
The US has a far more pro-market attitude than most of the rest of the Western world
Attitude is not the same as reality. If the US really were more pro-market, instead of just talking like it, we would not have given a massive bailout to the same investment banks that tanked the economy in 2008. (Nor would we have allowed the various regulatory schemes that enabled the crash to happen in the first place.)
- eli_gottlieb 13y ago>Yes, there is: governments are run by people, subject to the same incentives as people in any other part of society, including the perverse and misaligned incentives that cause "market failures" in other parts of society. Then explain the proven successes of state regulatory mechanisms. And no, that doesn't allow explaining them away by trying to pretend they've never happened.
- baddox 13y ago> Then explain the proven successes of state regulatory mechanisms. Easy: they are simply less efficient than market solutions to the same problems.
- tankenmate 13y agoproof please...
- pdonis 13y agoThen explain the proven successes of state regulatory mechanisms. Examples, please?
- clavalle 13y agoI don't have to worry about my next door neighbor starting a pig farm. I rode an elevator today without worrying about falling to my death. No one is spraying dioxin as a sealant on the streets in my area because it was the cheap option. There are, quite literally, a million examples like this that may be hard to think of because, when regulation works, you don't have to think about it.
- pdonis 13y agoYou're assuming that government regulation solves all these problems better than a free market system would. Let's see: I don't have to worry about my next door neighbor starting a pig farm. Do you live in a covenant community? I do, which means it isn't government regulations that are stopping my next door neighbor from starting a pig farm, but the voluntarily adopted by-laws of the community, funded by the dues paid by homeowners. Do you have any evidence that homeowners in such communities pay more for the same benefits, on average, than homeowners in towns and cities where the local government's zoning laws are the applicable regulations? I rode an elevator today without worrying about falling to my death. How much did you pay in taxes for that assurance? How much would you have paid in a free market where private insurance companies enforced safety regulations--i.e., the inspection certificate inside the elevator was issued by an inspector hired by the insurance company that had liability for any injuries caused by a defect in the elevator, rather than an inspector hired by the government? Do you have any evidence that the latter cost would be higher than the former for the same benefit? No one is spraying dioxin as a sealant on the streets in my area because it was the cheap option. I didn't know dioxin was even an option for street sealing, but let's assume you meant "some harmful substance". Once again, you're paying taxes for this benefit; do you have any evidence that you're getting the benefit more cheaply than you would in a free market system where roads were privately owned, and the owners were liable for damages to neighboring property owners, just as I would be liable if I dumped toxic waste on your lawn? when regulation works, you don't have to think about it. Yep, right up until it stops working catastrophically. Ask the residents of Gulf coast communities how well government regulation prevented them from suffering serious damage as a result of the Deepwater Horizon spill. In a free market, BP could not have just gone and started drilling with a nudge-nudge wink-wink from Federal regulators who had no real stake in the outcome and who made no serious effort to sanity check what they were doing; they would have had to convince the Gulf residents themselves, directly, that the risks of drilling were worth the benefits.
- Brakenshire 13y ago> Yes, there is: governments are run by people, subject to the same incentives as people in any other part of society, including the perverse and misaligned incentives that cause "market failures" in other parts of society. The same incentives exist in any system. In fact, in what you might call 'pro-market' sytems, you often find business people closely involved with regulation, and also a lot of government services sub-contracted out to private companies, which makes the incentives shift the other way. So, for instance, the incentives inherent in for-profit prisons led to the judge-kickback scandal: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kids_for_cash_scandal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kids_for_cash_scandal You're also going up against the lack of evidence for your position. As I say, in Europe, the countries with the highest levels of taxation and regulation often have the best anti-corruption reputations, the most well-functioning regulatory systems, and the most buoyant economies.
- pdonis 13y agoThe same incentives exist in any system. Yes; I never said otherwise. in what you might call 'pro-market' sytems, you often find business people closely involved with regulation I don't call these "pro-market" systems, precisely because business people being closely involved with regulation is not, IMO, "pro-market". It may be "pro-business", depending on the business, but businesses that succeed this way are not "pro-market". a lot of government services sub-contracted out to private companies That's not "pro-market" either; the companies may be private, but the demand they are satisfying is not, it's generated by the government. In Europe, the countries with the highest levels of taxation and regulation often have the best anti-corruption reputations, the most well-functioning regulatory systems, and the most buoyant economies References, please?
- jf22 13y agoRegarding corruption I just stumbled upon this the other day: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_corruption http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_corruption
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago> Yes, there is: governments are run by people, subject to the same incentives as people in any other part of society, including the perverse and misaligned incentives that cause "market failures" in other parts of society. That is simultaneously true and irrelevant. The price of good government is vigilance on the part of the population. People want to vote themselves a New Deal and a strong federal government without the trouble of amending the constitution to add the appropriate checks against the new powers the federal government claims by reinterpretation, here we are. Governments are terrible blunt instruments that can be simultaneously corrupt and incompetent, but somebody has got to build the roads and stop corporations from dumping toxic waste in the water supply.