10 ms·
Without morality, the market economy will destroy itself
- kingkawn 13y agoThe many legions of people more thoughtful than us all throughout the millennia who have moralized against greed might've made a dent by now if moralizing were the answer.
- gress 13y agoYeah we haven't found any new solutions to old problems for millennia, in fact progress stopped centuries ago. I wish people would just stop trying to improve the world and just enjoy being cynical about it instead.
- kingkawn 13y agoits interesting that you assume I mean then that cynicism is the answer. I think we have an economic structure that uses fear as its primary motivator. Fear of depression, homelessness, suffering, and death. Working toward a solution of quantifiable inspiration would be a much more meaningful approach. I think you can intentionally inspire people, since we all have experienced people who do it to us over and over again. So all that must be done is treat that as an abstract principle rather than intangibility, define it, and apply it more broadly.
- gress 13y agoYour original comment did sound cynical. This comment on the other hand sounds as though it is grounded in a morality.
- kingkawn 13y agoI agree but I am not moralizing, which I believe are different things. If there is an immoral action or event recurrently happening it is because the structure of society is allowing it to happen. It will not be solved through shaming anyone. It makes no more sense to shame poor people who are desperate for welfare than it does to shame wall street bankers. Both are products of the same system, and both groups can be given the space to change themselves through modifying the way things work rather than who is working in them.
- gress 13y agoShaming and moralizing aren't the same thing either. I agree with you about the structure of the system producing immoral actions, however I think that in order to change the structure, we must recognize the immorality otherwise this is just an empty abstraction.
- kingkawn 13y agoIt is finally powerful as an abstraction. Assigning the immorality to individuals is exactly what perpetuates the overall system.
- gress 13y agoSure - don't assign immorality to individuals. However you have to assign it to something - so what do you assign it to?
- kingkawn 13y agoIf someone is acting immorally, rather than condemning them think about how they came to be. Look at how the system corresponds to that. And then, ask how to change that system to encourage different behavior without using more abuse/punishment/rat traps to induce that new systemic output. I think you will find that few people desire to act immorally, but they also are bound within their system. They get defensive when you tell them they have to be different; they know it will not work given the framework they operate within. If instead you ask them how to change the system, allowing them to be better, they can be your ally. I do not think approaching them with a pre-formulated answer will as effectively draft them into the cause as genuinely asking them how they would do it.
- gress 13y agoI'm asking you, and it isn't working. That's not a good start. Also really, while I'm sympathetic to the idea that people's behavior is a largely a product of circumstance, if I ask a poor person who had resorted to crime to survive how to change the system, I expect familiar answers about making the system more fair. If I ask a Wall Street Banker, who is happily extracting maximum profits from the poor, regardless of cost, I expect familiar answers about how they shouldn't make poor economic decisions. I have actually spoken to people at all levels of society, and I haven't heard a lot of great solutions about how to change the system. Since you have either had different results from your conversations, or have ideas of your own, I invite you to share some here.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoWhat makes you think the world wouldn't be an ever darker place without it? What else do you suggest?
- kingkawn 13y agowe've spent a great deal of energy solving how to reverse engineer depression with moderate success. how about taking it the next step and figuring out how to quantifiably induce inspiration.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoor maybe they were wrong, and what they called "greed" was an ill defined and useless concept. In order to say what is "greed", one must usually define some means of obtaining wealth that are immoral. But given this one might as well say not to do immoral things, and forget the concept of greed. While the article was not unreasonable, I had the feeling he was trying to reinterpret these millennia of moralizing into something that made economic sense, and all he could come up with was "monopolies are bad". Which is true in most cases, but I don't think he made a convincing connection with personal ethical behavior.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoIt's not like anyone ever just said "don't be greedy" and nothing more. But even then: http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greed http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greed Also see: selfishness, double standards, externalizing risks and costs while the reaping profits. Such things (can) stem from greed, and they can add up to catastrophic effects. These effects linger, while the "gains" from greed end when the greedy person dies. >a convincing connection with personal ethical behavior aggregate = 0; last_aggregate = 0; while (true) { for (i = peeps.length; i--;) { aggregate += peeps[i].behaviour(world.state, last_aggregate); } world.update(aggregate); last_aggregate = aggregate; }
- yetanotherphd 13y agoIf you want to define greed as imposing externalities on others (e.g. someone who finds that burning plastic in their backyard is legal because of some loophole, and so creates a garbage disposal facility there) then I agree that this is something we should try to avoid, but this is not what has been preached for millennia. In fact the discussion on gentrification shows that most people still cannot distinguish what is and is not an externality. I couldn't understand what your code was supposed to prove, probably because it was full of premature optimization and mutable state.
- PavlovsCat 13y ago> If you want to define greed as imposing externalities on others No, but I mentioned those things because they can result from greed, which is why greed is bad. If greed didn't result in destructive action, or if the negative effects were borne by those causing them, it wouldn't matter. And those things, multiplied by millions or even billions of people in an endless loop, can lead to vast destruction, too. > this is not what has been preached for millennia Whoever oppresses the poor to increase his own wealth, or gives to the rich, will only come to poverty -- Proverb 22:16
- mpweiher 13y ago"It's not about morality versus markets" (my emphasis) Markets are a great optimization mechanism. It is up to societies to decide what they should optimize.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoMarkets optimize whatever you define as being capital, distributing it to the owners of whatever you define as being property. They are not moral in and of themselves, neither do they achieve anything that another optimization process couldn't achieve if it likewise relied on massively parallel, breadth-first heuristic searches of the possibility space. But of course, that takes all the delicious magic out of them, so people are going to have to yell something about freedom now.
- kingkawn 13y agoThis is a wonderful way to say it. My further extrapolation is to turn the full might of the market to advertise and sell poverty relief without treating it like charity but instead treating it like a product. None of the moralizing, just focus on what the purchaser will get out of the exchange, like any other product.
- ams6110 13y agoReminds me of "Our Constitution was made only for a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other." (John Adams)
- pablovidal85 13y agoAll social problems will be eventually solved through technology, not morality.
- wsinks 13y agoMorality was one of the first technologies.
- thenerdfiles 13y agoIs this Nietzschean or something? What is it saying?
- ams6110 13y agoAt some point in our past we transitioned from being an amoral animal to a self-aware species with notions of morality. Certain things/behaviors are right and others are wrong. That clearly had a survival advantage.
- thenerdfiles 13y agoMoral facts are not self-evident. We became aware of disagreement, but about the games we use to describe right and wrong. It's what comes after the "because". Saying "X is wrong" and "Y knows X is wrong" mean two very different things depending on your analysis. "Notions of morality" is about the first statement and about the second. Does Y know X is wrong in virtue of the moral fact that X is wrong? If grass is green, there's something I'm learning when I read "Grass is green" — or is it upon seeing grass that I know grass is green? The point here is the features of facts: one does not see the wrongness of an act in the way that one sees grass is green, irrespective to the question of language. Now, of course, morality is primarily codified into symbols — do facts exist here, behind the veil of language? Perhaps. But the main question here is the structure of a fact: Is it a picture? If I know the constant of gravity, I know something about the shape of galaxies through relativity. I can see regularity across the heavens. I can test it and measure its components, but only in virtue of axiomitization, which is linguistic. Well, how does one test morality? Does one collect report on opinion, or does one look into the world to discover their structure? Certainly reports on moral opinion will be picture-like, but do they disclose the structure we would find if morality could be discovered in the world without reports on it? Is direct evidence possible without the existence of indirect evidence?
- michaelcampbell 13y agoThe latest podcast of Freakonomics discussed this; believe it or don't, but it was quite thought provoking nonetheless.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gametheoretic 13y agoThere are no moral phenomena, only moral interpretations.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- elgabogringo 13y agoWithout morality, people will destroy themselves regardless of their socio-political-economic system.
- lazyjones 13y agoI didn't find a single argument in favor of the claim in the title, i.e. that the market economy will somehow destroy itself without morality. It's just a firm belief the author has, or perhaps a hope ...
- scotty79 13y agoSome causes of market destruction could be monopolies (that grow powerful enough to close market to new entrants) and "market for lemons". Not sure how morality could help though.
- calibraxis 13y agoYes, there's zillions of better articles. But why would a serious argument against markets be voted up here? (Any serious market abolitionist would explain pervasive externalities, enormous inefficiency of markets, rewarding participants for acting sociopathically and punishing others, etc.) But this is a place where people discuss hawking things called "minimum viable products" and so on.
- Symmetry 13y agoI've been meaning to read The Bourgeois Virtues, a book entirely about the importance of morality in functioning market economies. But while morality is very important in a market economy, planned and traditional economies destroy themselves even more quickly in the face of moral breakdown.
- yk 13y agoFor the argument, see Schumpeter's Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy.
- Tycho 13y ago"Friedrich Hayek once said that to complain about the workings of the market was like complaining about the weather. But at least the Met Office never colonised our souls." Seems to be a lot of expressions like that in left wing journalism. "Colonised our souls." Like all of a sudden you're reading a Yeats poem.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Brakenshire 13y agoIn my experience you almost never see phrases like that being used, certainly not in news sections. In any case, this article is an opinion piece, on Comment Is Free, which is a free-for-all, and it's not written by a journalist, but by an aide to the Archbishop of Canterbury. For those who don't know, the Archbishop of Canterbury is the leader of the Church of England, and the current incumbent, Justin Welby, used to a finance executive in the oil industry, and tends to be engaged with these sorts of issues.
- Theodores 13y agoWe haven't actually given a genuine 'market economy' a chance to prove itself. One critical aspect of this is taxation. We all know that the big multinational companies can put their profits somewhere else, where they will not get taxed. In most cases this is fully legal even if it is morally wrong. There is also the matter of subsidy and when the government bails a company out. Old business models get kept running when the invisible hand of the market would have swept them to one side, maybe to allow new business models to take hold. Then there is outright corruption - backhanders to win government contracts. This is not 'letting the market decide'. Even worse there is the likes of Lockheed Martin able to own the government, listen in through NSA on rival contractors bids and win favourable contracts for themselves and the companies they do business with. Then there is the small matter of law. Larger businesses can get away with polluting the environment and running unfair business practices that mean their rivals are not playing on a level playing field. Also, there are costs to business that are not paid for by those businesses. If the taxpayer is expected to pay for the road to an industrial estate on a greenfield site just to get some lousy business to setup in that area then again this is not 'market economy'. Also there are those government services that are sold on the private marketplace. For instance, the market in weather information, e.g. for television news, should be a profitable one, however, if the government's private arm of their weather service - e.g. the UK Met Office - competes in that space then again things are not fair. However you look at it we have not got a 'market economy', we have something corrupt, with cronies and their backhanders rigging the marketplace. It is not free and fair trade. We can forget about 'morality', let's just do things by the book.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoReal capitalism has never worked "by the book". "The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and expecting a different result."
- iterative 13y ago"Many have argued that capitalism does not offer a satisfactory moral message. But that is like saying that calculus does not contain cabrohydrates, amino acids, or other essential nutrients. Everything fails by irrevelant standards." -- Thomas Sowell
- Ygg2 13y agoWait does that mean slavery is morally neutral? Because capitalism predates feudalism as the economic model and slavery predates feudalism.
- johnbm 13y agoThe real problem is that capitalism does not care about efficiency, it only cares about billing someone else for any inefficiencies you create. See: Enterprise IT.
- EarthLaunch 13y agoThis is true in the sense that a market economy, i.e. capitalism, is based on morality. Few people are aware of the moral justification for capitalism. Morality trumps politics. Without a moral justification, the market economy won't survive. > "No social system (and no human institution or activity of any kind) can survive without a moral base. On the basis of the altruist morality, capitalism had to be—and was—damned from the start." -Ayn Rand, Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal, 30
- PavlovsCat 13y agoWhen was capitalism ever based on altruism? Isn't the idea rather that everybody being as selfish as possible magically leads to good results?
- lumberjack 13y agoThe idea you are referring to is about self interest not selfishness.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoI know that the idea is enlightened self-interest. Is it in the enlightened self-interest of a person that after they died, there is still life in the Universe? Is it in my enlightened self-interest that those who starve and have no water have a better life? What, exactly, is the difference between self-interest and selfishness? Is one not just a euphemism for the other?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoInitially it was based on that. Then, when that didn't work, it shifted over to Ayn Rand's "material self-interest is the only good" system of ethics.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- josu 13y agoThis is a bit off topic, but I hate it when they use pictures of malls to illustrate capitalism. I consider myself a capitalist and I despise malls, they represent mindless consumerism. They might be somewhat related to capitalism, but they will never be a paradigmatic example.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoCapitalism needs consumerism to deal with its overproduction crises. The imagined "sober Protestant bourgeois ethic" of capitalism stopped having any basis in reality hundreds of years ago, around the time usury and Enclosure Laws, and Poor Laws were used to evict the peasantry from their land to forcibly create a landless proletariat.
- pdonis 13y agoCapitalism needs consumerism to deal with its overproduction crises. This only illustrates the fact that "capitalism" and "free markets" are not synonymous. In a free market, producers who overproduce go out of business.
- javajosh 13y agoActually, in a free market overproducers try like hell to increase demand. They do that through better advertising, which these days means directed advertising. Mass media (starting with newspapers) has really changed the way the world works because it gives producers a way to affect the very fabric of society. Advertisements, TV commercials, billboards - we just accept these as part of the landscape. We accept the constant intrusion of private enterprise to influence our thought, which is strange indeed. Mark Twain wrote a remarkable little book called "A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court", which to me is the quintessentially American book on capitalism as it is fetishized by Ayn Rand etc. The man travels back in time, and proceeds to use his technical knowledge to enrich himself, and civilize the medieval society. One of the steps he takes is to introduce advertising to the knights shields. This is presented un-ironically. Of course Twain grew up in a very different time where the ratio of city to country was far different, and cities themselves were much humbler affairs. It was easy (and indeed the default) to be "in nature". So the product of "American ingenuity" no matter how crass represented lovely "civilization", and one could turn away from it if one didn't like it, and venture back into the forest. But now, with our mega-cities there are few forests left, and they are far away, and if we turn away from one advertisement we are just confronted with another and another and then another.
- flyinglizard 13y agoI always wonder why people bring up the 2008 crisis as an example of the problems with Capitalism; in my view, it was just the self balancing mechanisms inherent in the market economy kicking in. The fact the crisis happened at all is a testament to the viability and adaptability of Capitalism. State sponsored market deficiencies can go for much longer and have worse implications. I don't like the tone of that article at all. When you start demanding that morality, for all its subjectivity and relativity, be involved with economics, you invite troubles. The next step is for morality to be mandated through regulations. Such regulations rarely do more than benefit specific players, those who know how to bend the rules or those with higher up connections. While I was expecting the author to call for such regulation, he surprisingly didn't. In my view, the correct way of fighting monopolies would be using the great social tools at our disposal to make consumers more informed about the distant implications of their buying decisions. This will create an informed Capitalism, one where in the consumers are the ultimate regulators.
- pdonis 13y agoIn my view, the correct way of fighting monopolies would be using the great social tools at our disposal to make consumers more informed about the distant implications of their buying decisions. This will create an informed Capitalism, one where in the consumers are the ultimate regulators. Can't upvote this enough.
- nooneelse 13y agoGreat idea/ideal, and I share it... but until I'm wearing a HUD that can tell me what materials and processes in which factories and ports were used at each step of production and distribution contributing to each lot of cereal in the store, I'm not really informed enough at the point of economic decision to accurately reflect my utility function through my purchases. And good luck getting the producers of goods to share details even approaching that. As a class, they routinely fight additional labeling of their products, getting access to their production and distribution databases will be a far worse fight.
- james3 13y ago
- RougeFemme 13y agoI used to believe that at least the consumer market economy would start to correct itself once we reached the point where there were no longer enough gainfully employed people to buy the goods and services being offered. And that would push corporations to start to re-hire the unemployed and not slash to the bone in pursuit of astronomical quarterly gains. But that was a very myopic, "developed" nation view. I hadn't considered the use of cheap global labor and the rise of the middle and upper classes in developing nations that would provide the necessary demand for goods and services, making the "workers" in developed nations mere surplus to be discarded/ignored. (I'm watching "A Christmas Carol" right now.)
- xname 13y agoAuthor: "Malcolm Brown is director of mission and public affairs for the Church of England".
- resdirector 13y agoFrom the headline I thought this was a stunning result from academia. Then in the first two paragraphs I read the words "Pope", "Rush Limbaugh", "Archbishop", "Jesus", "Marxist", etc.
- kenster07 13y agoWithout morality, ANY social system, not just a market economy, will have problems, since many moral constructs directly lead to social stability. Some basic examples: 1) Thou shalt not steal, cheat, murder, etc... 2) Notions of karma -- i.e. everything you do unto others will come back to you.
- mortyseinfeld 13y agoFor some reason, I thought of Rahm Emanual (used to be Obama's chief of staff) when he said "You never want a serious crisis to go to waste" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1yeA_kHHLow http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1yeA_kHHLow Unfortunately, you have leftist statists that want market economies to fail so they can impose their statist, opressive regimes on people under the guise of "helping the people"
- unclebucknasty 13y ago>Unfortunately, you have leftist statists that want market economies to fail so they can impose their statist, opressive regimes on people under the guise of "helping the people" You really believe this is the case with people like Emanuel and the Obama admin in general? Because, I wonder: what do you think their endgame is? What is their true motivation for wanting to establish a statist, oppresive regime? It seems to me that we currently have a corporatist regime. If I am to choose between rule by corporations (where the motive is profit) and rule by the state (where I presumably have a voice), I'd choose the latter. Problem is, however, we currently have the worst of both worlds: rule by a corporatist state.
- mortyseinfeld 13y agoThe bottom line (a big one) is that corporations don't have guns and can take you away.