4 ms·
There must be some kind of Yogi Berra-ism to describe "how bad" the insurance is that so many people wish they could still buy. Insurance against a condition t
by ams6110 13y ago
There must be some kind of Yogi Berra-ism to describe "how bad" the insurance is that so many people wish they could still buy.
Insurance against a condition that already exists is not insurance.
Preventive care should not be something you look to insurance to pay for. Do you expect to be insured against your weekly grocery shopping bill? Your utilities? Your rent?
- temporary1312 13y ago"Insurance against a condition that already exists is not insurance," but I've twice had coverage for other unrelated conditions (rehab for a broken leg, and treatment for severe pneumonia) denied because I was hospitalized years earlier for a chronic illness having to do with the digestive tract.
- hsitz 13y agoSounds like you're extending intent of quote to be about "pre-existing conditions". Obamacare requires that health insurance policies cover pre-existing conditions, which is another difference from other types of insurance. The only way this could reasonably be required would be if all individuals are required to always carry insurance, which is what gives rise to the much-debated "individual mandate". All of this makes good sense, in my mind. You don't say why you were denied coverage for broken leg rehab and pneumonia treatment. It seems a stretch for it to have been denied as pre-existing condition, but one of the problems when insurance companies were allowed to deny for pre-existing conditions was that they did often make non-sensical stretches to deny. I think reason for denial in your case was probably for something else, perhaps something like an insurer's "annual cap" on coverage (but not that b/c your previous coverage was years earlier), another thing that now is gone thanks to Obamacare.
- temporary1312 13y agoYes, I was straight up denied coverage for broken leg rehab and pneumonia coverage for having the intestinal issues, and only through fighting it was it covered. It was not anything other than insurance companies being dickish, hadn't reached the annual cap or anything like that. Other friends of mine with chronic illnesses have had similar issues. Needless to say, I'm looking forward to that provision of obamacare.
- hsitz 13y ago"Preventive care should not be something you look to insurance to pay for. Do you expect to be insured against your weekly grocery shopping bill? Your utilities? Your rent?" In fact, Obamacare mandates that much preventive care be provided for free. Health insurance is different from many kinds of insurance, which you hope never to collect on. With healthcare insurance you're very likely to use at least some covered services every year. Preventive care is the kind of care everyone should have every year, and it is the kind of care that best reduces health costs, making it best for patients and for nation as a whole. That's why Obamacare requires that it be covered 100%, even in least expensive bronze plans. This encourages people to get preventive care and prevents bigger expenses for them later on. I'm not knocking Obamacare. Hardly, I'm a proponent of it. It makes sense.
- hga 13y ago"Preventive care is the kind of care everyone should have every year, and it is the kind of care that best reduces health costs...." BZZZT. As I understand it, study after study shows preventive case does not result in cost reductions. E.g. look at the controversial mammogram screening recommendations that came out a while ago. There are many other mechanisms where not immediately obvious things come into play. That's not to say we shouldn't do it, look at the backlash to those mammogram recommendations, which would have killed a friend of mine in her early 40s if she and her doctor had followed them, just that they will overall cost more.
- hsitz 13y agoBZZZT. Preventive care in general is cheapest and study after study shows that it is. That doesn't mean that certain kinds of preventive care might not work. Of course if they don't work then they're not cost effective. But the fact that smart, simple tests to catch diseases or conditions before they've progressed is most cost effective method has been established for a long time. Heck, just having patients get in for an annual physical and quick look over from a doctor is cost-effective form of preventive care. That's why ACA requires it to be covered. I do agree that unwise or poorly designed preventive care, usually in the form of excessive and expensive testing that is poorly chosen and often has too many false positives, is one of the big problems running up medical costs. That does not change the fact that proper preventive care is most cost-effective form of healthcare.
- jasomill 13y agoCall it what you will, but health insurance that doesn't cover preventive care and pre-existing conditions would be all but useless to me, personally, due to expensive ($15,000/month, give or take) preventive treatment necessary to properly treat severe hemophilia. With that said, hard cases make bad law, and the argument against immediate coverage of pre-existing conditions — healthy people will rationally choose to remain un- or underinsured, then seek more comprehensive coverage when diagnosed with something that requires expensive treatment — is reasonable. It's also a decent argument for universal health care at a reasonable minimum standard.