4 ms·
Like many road-safety campaigners, Lines is very persuasive with his argument. "There are 200 people killed and 2,500 seriously injured on London's roads each y
by Zak 17y ago
Like many road-safety campaigners, Lines is very persuasive with his argument. "There are 200 people killed and 2,500 seriously injured on London's roads each year, and it costs £1.2 billion [about $1.9 billion]," he said.
This argument is not persuasive at all. Lines offers no evidence that regulating speed by GPS would produce a net decrease in traffic fatalities, injuries or economic damage. It is reasonable to assume that if all vehicles were required to equip such a device, some of each of the following (in unknown proportions) would occur:
* Some crashes caused in whole or in part by excess speed would not occur.
* Some crashes that could have been avoided by accelerating suddenly and briefly exceeding the speed limit would occur.
* Some people would be exposed to dangerous situations, such as criminal assault that they may have been able to flee in an unrestricted car. It is probably safe to assume that some criminals will figure out how to bypass the devices on their own cars.
* Some people requiring urgent medical care will suffer increased harm or death because they could not reach a hospital as quickly.
And I'm probably forgetting a few things. Without some analysis of the likely changes in these outcomes, it's impossible to say whether the harms cited by Lines support the introduction of such devices.
- wildwood 17y agoThe sad thing is, even if it led to a net increase in death and injury due to the causes you described, the traffic regulators would likely still see it as a gain, because it would reduce the number of "traffic deaths". (Even if it lead to a larger increase in "crime deaths" and/or "medical trauma deaths".) It's another case of being careful what metrics you use, and what you optimize for.