3 ms·
I have a question. Can government issue gag order to security firm doing audit and prevent them from releasing backdoors or intentional weaknesses they discove
by nabla9 13y ago
I have a question.
Can government issue gag order to security firm doing audit and prevent them from releasing backdoors or intentional weaknesses they discover?
- tptacek 13y agoNo.
- whyme 13y agoI'm surprised you're so confident considering how many experts were shocked to discover how far the US govt had been able to go.
- tptacek 13y agoComes from an understanding of how service providers actually get gagged: the courts actively issue a gag rule based on orders they themselves issued. That's can't be true of basic science.
- shiven 13y agoWhat if the powers that be decide to "classify" the results/reports? I would guess that would be a big legal hurdle. But if things get to that point, a copy the report would probably show up on wikileaks... I guess?
- eli 13y agoThat's not how classification works.
- tptacek 13y agoIt's also not how research works. For something to be restrained from publication, the government needs to know it exists. But with new research results, they can't know what to restrain until it's too late. They could try passing a law outlawing security research, but: good luck with that.
- geoffschmidt 13y agoIt's not normally how classification works, but then there's the Born Secret doctrine that was (is?) applied to information about nuclear weapons: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Born_secret http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Born_secret The NSA isn't going to swoop in and claim that the results of the Truecrypt audit were born secret. But the answer to nabla9's question is yes, legal precedent exists in the United States for restraining the publication of original research when it is perceived to damage vital national security interests.
- amenod 13y agoProbably not. But they can contact a security reseach company so they make a "crowdsourced" audit project, perform it and still leave a backdoor or two uncovered. TrueCrypt gets an official audit and NSA keeps the backdoors - win-win. </sarcasm> And there is less chance that anyone else will perform an audit in near future. :(
- mafribe 13y agoI am not familiar with the legal situation. However, one needs also to consider extra-juridical means. A security company that does not comply with the demands of the relevant security services is unlikely ever to do major business again in the country where it is based.