7 ms·
It would be much better to have 100 more cars on the road during rush hour, right?
by jrockway 13y ago
It would be much better to have 100 more cars on the road during rush hour, right?
- etjossem 13y agoIt's faster to damage a single bus than slash 100 tires. The protesters don't care about the state of rush hour. They care about what the corporate buses represent: large tech corporations increasing the wealth gap and raising rent in SF/Oakland. It's a fact that each stalled bus will have a bottom-line impact on Google or one of its partners. That said, smashing windows is not an effective way to win allies. It just makes it a little bit easier to dismiss opponents of gentrification as supporters of vandalism. These "activists" are alienating the very public officials who would otherwise support measures that favor existing residents (e.g. rent control and stabilization).
- diab0lic 13y agoI can't imagine they were protesting the literal act of using a bus to ferry employees to work. Rather this was an easy way to target members of a group the protestors feel wronged by/animosity towards.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Crito 13y agoThey should consider reviewing their tactics then, because it sure as hell seems as though the buses are one of their complaints.
- minikites 13y agoIt would be much better to have affordable housing for all instead of the wealthy pricing out the ordinary.
- adamnemecek 13y agoCan you really blame Google for this though? Seems a bit misplaced.
- PeterisP 13y agoCorrection, 'affordable housing for some not all' is what's implied here - there's not enough housing for all, and the only way it's going to stay affordable, given the current housing policy, is if all the googlers get kicked out of the place for good.
- Pxtl 13y agoIn that case they should be smashing windows at City Hall (or not anywhere, preferably). The municipality must be up to its gills in property tax cash and is the only people who can properly manage the response to this skyrocketing demand for housing. This isn't Vancouver or Tokyo or Manhattan, there's room to build more housing and drive down the supply/demand imbalance, and money to be made doing it... but without the municipality leading the way on intensification, it's not going to get better.
- jaibot 13y agoI believe a referendum to allow for some new housing to be built was voted down "because it would drive rents up". Sigh.
- cbhl 13y agoI don't see that happening unless the people who already own property in the city suddenly decide en masse that they're okay with repealing laws that prevent you from building tall apartment complexes to preserve the "look" of the city.
- PeterisP 13y agoAs far as I recall, the power to decide how things should be rests with all the people, not just the landlords. The renters outnumber them, and they have the ability, the rights and the reason to achieve cheaper rents by allowing to build apartment complexes.
- cbhl 13y agoTrue, but a renter is also disincentivized to vote for allowing people to build apartment complexes because of NIMBYism -- they don't want to be kicked out of their current living arrangements so that someone can spend 6 months building a new apartment complex in its place that might have lower rent. The people who would unabashedly vote for the repeal such laws would likely be the people who don't live in SF yet but who want to live/move there.
- k-mcgrady 13y agoBy providing free transportation from SF Google employees are encouraged to live there. Why not live closer to work? It would probably result in a few more cars on the road but a lot of the employees would move closer to Google freeing up apartments for people who actually work at businesses in SF and HAVE to live there. NB: I have no stake in this, I like in Ireland.
- kkowalczyk 13y ago1. Shortage of housing is even worse near Google campus than in SF 2. Angry mob or your opinions should not dictate where people choose to live. I could offer many suggestions as to how you should live YOUR life to better suit MY goal and ideas, but I don't because that would be stupid. You should choose a place to live that suits YOU the best and you should offer the same curtesy to others. The "occupy Google bus" movement is straight-up bullying.
- ecspike 13y agoEven with the few new construction projects happening in MTV, it's not enough to house everyone. Apartments go incredibly fast. Google employees are competing with all the other big companies in the South Bay(EBay/Apple/Facebook amongst others) plus the yearly influx of interns that takes a bunch of apartments off the market for 6 months at a time.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gress 13y agoYeah - people shouldn't complain - they should just shut up and get a job that pays them a 6 figure salary and provides an air conditioned luxury coach to take them to work.
- simoncion 13y agoEdit: Oh, heh. I mis-read your statement. Regardless, I'll keep my original comment below. Do with it what you will. _________________ 1) 6-figures is middle-of-the-road when it comes to meeting living expenses in SV. You will never own an urban house (and will likely not own a suburban house) on that salary in the area. 2) Have you, like, ever ridden in a big bus before? They're pretty nausea-inducing and tend to get stuck in the same traffic that every other ground vehicle gets stuck in. Their only advantages are traffic reduction and (maybe, if you can fight the nausea) the ability to catch up on email during your commute in. 3) I did the commute-down-the-peninsula thing for a couple of years. It was also pretty miserable and not very cheap (but far cheaper than owning, parking, and maintaining a car). I can't argue that Caltrain is worse than these buses, but I can argue that they're both pretty miserable.
- what_ever 13y agoI am not taking any side, but I don't think this argument is valid. If there were no shuttles, I think most of the Google employees would prefer to stay close to MTV instead of an hour away. I know that I would not like to drive for at least an hour on each side in traffic on 101 everyday. I would just rent an apartment in MTV or Palo Alto.
- hoytie 13y agoI think the situation would be drastically different if the buses didn't exist, for better or worse. Workers would make completely different choices in where they live, and it's not likely they would choose the same neighborhoods that the buses afford them the convenience of. And just maybe SV companies would change their highly suburban and unsustainable real estate policies. Just because 1 bus going form a to b is better than 100 cars going from a to b doesn't justify the policy of the buses or even demonstrate they're sustainable.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- wankerrific 13y agoNo - it would be better to have those 100 people living down near where they work - in Mountain View, Sunnyvale, Fremont, Santa Clara, Milpitas, etc. The GBus only solves a problem it creates currently.