4 ms·
Those people may have a family, and would much prefer a suburban home in a good school district. For the last 50 or so years, "urban" has always had the proper
by jseliger 13y ago
Those people may have a family, and would much prefer a suburban home in a good school district.
For the last 50 or so years, "urban" has always had the property "bad school district." I wonder how preferences would change if urban school districts were functional, or at least more functional than most of them are now.
In addition, safe and functional urban neighborhoods tend to be expensive because of zoning (see Edward Glaeser's The Triumph of the City for more on this). What would happen if we had cities in which housing weren't so expensive?
- mc32 13y agoOne other issue with urban schools is that they're mixed --some good some bad, but often cities try to raise the performance of poor-performing students by 'busing' them to schools with students with aptitude. One, this adds uncertainty --is your pupil going to end up at your choice of school? Two, the students with poor aptitude often are not elevated by good aptitude students, so often this effort goes for naught.
- jseliger 13y agoVery true—and the WSJ, when it was still a good paper, had a long article about this dynamic in Seattle: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB116519951912839643.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB116519951912839643.html . As far as I know, however, busing is more or less over in Seattle, such that most parents can figure out based on housing locale where their kids are going to go to school.
- jstelly 13y agoSeattle is actually set up fairly well for this. While it isn't painless to commute between Seattle and the east side, it is certainly simpler to do so than commute to/from San Francisco and its suburbs. We are located in Bellevue and we have a pretty good split between people who live in Seattle and people who live on the east side.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gte910h 13y ago>For the last 50 or so years, "urban" has always had the property "bad school district." I wonder how preferences would change if urban school districts were functional, or at least more functional than most of them are now. There is also the question: What is a good school district? Are the schools themselves the actual cause of high test scores or the involved parents? How much does it matter if there are some low performers at your school if YOUR kids are learning fine?