4 ms·
Actually, it would be kind of nice to have both... is there some law of nature which prevents them co-occurring?
by jameshart 13y ago
Actually, it would be kind of nice to have both... is there some law of nature which prevents them co-occurring?
- mhurron 13y ago> is there some law of nature which prevents them co-occurring? Yes, your expected to give up all semblance of having a life outside your children once you have them.
- dangerlibrary 13y agoNot of nature, but of economics. For instance, you can absolutely have both if you are wealthy enough to afford private school or the rent / price premiums in neighborhoods with both good schools and trendy bars.
- HarryHirsch 13y agoThere is a confluence of factors, I think: rigid zoning laws that prevent mixed-use neighbourhoods, the car-orientedness of recent construction (think cul-de-sac-neighbourhoods with one single outlet to a major highway), and of course the fact that once you have kids you are not supposed to have a social life any longer. American town planning has been a disaster since time immemorial.
- ahmadss 13y agoBoulder and Austin fit the bill for having both. DC, not so much (in the education realm, but with new charter schools popping up in DC, the situation is getting better).
- JunkDNA 13y agoA person's priorities in life just change. I in no way ascribe to the "helicopter parent" approach to raising kids, but having kids changed me in fundamental ways that cause my outlook on life to change in a manner that often surprises me. Case in point: I used to be a movie buff. I loved watching movies. Now, I have the ultimate setup for watching movies and it doesn't even interest me. I have other things (not even necessarily always spending time with my toddlers) that I would rather spend 2.5+ hours doing (getting sleep being a prime contender).
- jameshart 13y agoOh, I kind of agree; but I also think that there's value in remaining yourself too, and not giving up everything for your kids. Not least because I think it can help your relationship with the person with whom you started the family in the first place. I just wish it was possible to live in a neighborhood which has good schools, nice neighborhood kids who you can trust to babysit, combined with somewhere within walking distance that's worth going to when you've got a sitter.
- mathattack 13y agoYou can remain yourself, but your priorities shift. Even with restaurants, you look for those that are stroller friendly and have enough other kids that you don't feel bad when lunch winds up on the floor. The problem with schools is that it is a very large entrenched organization, with lots of special interests (politicians, teachers, administration, etc) who don't want to give up monopoly power. The central organizations suck in a lot of money, and don't improve quality. There are ways to fight this (more charters, close bad schools, etc) but it's very hard and requires a lot of different folks in government willing to fight special interests.
- jameshart 13y agoYour idea of a fun date night with your SO must be very different to mine.
- mathattack 13y agoWelcome to life with kids.
- randomdata 13y agoI have noticed a similar change in my life in the past few years and I do not even have kids. I have always just attributed it to getting older.
- 13y ago
- rayiner 13y agoIt's largely a failure of American urban planning combined with the implications of American welfare policy. On the urban planning side, American cities spend huge amounts of time and effort preventing the demolition of old housing and the construction of housing. This drives up the price of housing. On the welfare policy side, American states corral all their poor people into their large cities. In Manhattan, riverfront property might be dedicated either to expensive condos (upper west side), or public housing (lower east side). The suburbs, for their part, go to great lengths to prevent the introduction of services for lower-income people. In most cities, #2 is a bigger problem than #1. If you're willing to compromise on space, living in the suburbs often isn't dramatically cheaper. In theory, getting a 1,500 square foot house would be cheaper in the suburbs versus the city, but suburban municipalities tend to discourage the construction of smaller houses, so often the choice is between 1,500 square feet in the city, or 3,000 square feet in the suburbs, at not altogether dissimilar prices factoring in the cost of commuting and cars. The biggest problem is schools. In most places, you have to pay for public schools even if you send your kid to private school. And public schools in cities are almost uniformly terrible, not because public schools in cities must intrinsically be terrible, but because as a result of #2, urban school districts are 90%+ low-income. Putting a bunch of poor kids all together in the same school is not a recipe for success. People like to paint it as a funding problem, but its a socioeconomic demographics problem. In Illinois, schools inside Chicago spend almost 40% more per student than schools outside Chicago, but perform far below those outside the city. Now of course, even the most progressive parents aren't willing to send their children to schools where 90% of the kids come from welfare homes, disproportionately don't have fathers, etc. And they don't want to pay $10,000 per year (for parochial schools), or $20,000+ (for non-religious schools) to send their kids to private schools. So they move to the suburbs, where they can send their kids to socioeconomically homogenous public schools, and take advantage of the services for which they're paying for anyway. I think the confluence of these factors is really unfortunate, and has an unfortunate impact on American families. First, I think it discourages people who might want kids from having kids. Second, it robs kids of the wonderfully enriching experience of living in cities, in close proximity to other people.
- sliverstorm 13y agoTrade-offs. You have limited $$; would you rather live in the neighborhood with excellent schools and no bar scene, or the neighborhood with good schools and a good bar scene? The neighborhoods with excellent schools and excellent bar scenes exist, but you and I mere mortals are priced out of them.
- mathattack 13y agoIndeed. NYC has Tribeca. There's a reason that a few good schools and great restaurants are in close proximity to so many hedge funds. :-)