3 ms·
The problem is not whether the protocol is secure - the problem is that there's no way we can tell. Historically, that means that it's likely not to be secure.
by ColinWright 13y ago
The problem is not whether the protocol is secure - the problem is that there's no way we can tell. Historically, that means that it's likely not to be secure.
With regards this counter-challenge. The crypto here is known to be poor. If this counter-challenge cannot be broken, then it shows that the challenge issued by Telegram is no proof of security.
SO in short,
* we don't know if no one can read the Telegram-encyphered messages,
* the challenge provides effectively zero evidence that it's secure,
* Telegram will proclaim loudly that no one has broken their crypto,
* non-specialists will be fooled by this.
If I haven't answered your question, perhaps you could be more explicit as to what you're not understanding.
- clebio 13y agoThis is an excellent answer. You get right to the core of it, quite clearly, which is that this has naught to do with the crypto itself. But that: > If this counter-challenge cannot be broken, then it shows that the challenge issued by Telegram is no proof of security.