7 ms·
You can spend $9,599 on a Mac Pro, but should you?
- bliti 13y agoDoes the PC market offer a similar clone case as the one on the Pro?
- csmuk 13y agoNo we have better ones. You know which we can replace bits of.
- girvo 13y agoDepends on your definition of better.
- csmuk 13y agoUpgradeable, replaceable parts, redundancy, better storage options, cheaper, doesn't accidentally get trash put in the top. And that's just the case. I have nothing but contempt for the Mac Pro design - it's style over substance to the extreme.
- girvo 13y agoAnd I like it's style, and Windows won't cut it, so for me the trade offs are okay :) Hence, depends on your definition of better. Computers are trade offs. Always have been. Your choice of trade offs is not inherently better than someone else's. (this is academic, btw, I'm not getting any of the computers in question)
- csmuk 13y agoAll computers are trade offs but when you start trading sensible things for appearance then it's just idiocy. It's the Ugg boot of computers. Looks pretty and keeps your feet warm but you can't get it wet and it isn't waterproof, they fuck up your feet and fall to bits. I'd rather have a pair of Berghaus explorers, warm and dry feet and for them to still be on one piece after a 20 mile hike (HP Z820). Don't really care about the OS - you can get where you need to with virtualization.
- girvo 13y agoI disagree, but I think I'll leave it at that, as I'm obviously not explaining my point well enough...
- Shivetya 13y agobetter as in not needing separate power supplies and cases to have reasonable storage options. better is not needing to buy a new machine (I know, not confirmed but they never aren't offering) to upgrade components. better is having a user upgradeable storage (the ssd is not user upgradable even with tricks according to some). While it certainly is an interesting case, stylish for some, its pure form over function. They have essentially made a Mac Pro Mini / Mac Pro iPad ... as in what you bought it what your stuck with. Want to upgrade to a new processor or newer video card, well buy a newer machine.
- coldtea 13y agoSo the kind that needs personal hassle? I'll pass, I'm a professional in another field, not a PC mechanic.
- csmuk 13y agoThat's fine until you take your Pro back to apple and they don't have your configuration available and you have to wait 3 weeks for a replacement (this does happen a lot with non standard apple build to order devices). Even worse with an XServe I inherited: they couldn't replace it in warranty. Ended up with a supermicro 1U with debian on it in under 24 hours from buy to install. My HP: redundant PSU, disks, next day service for all parts or replacement unit. No competition. I can't afford the downtime.
- subsection1h 13y agoVisiting an Apple store to have a part replaced is free if your time is worth nothing.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 13y agoOr you know, I can send it and get it back. What kind of professional doesn't have a backup machine or two? Heck, a professional of the kind that needs a Mac Pro can also afford an assistant to take to the Apple store... Nor it's like checking the damage on my home-built PC, tinkering, ordering parts and replacing them will take me less time...
- bliti 13y agoMy question is related to the actual rounded case. Is something like it available for the PC market? I'm tired of the standard boxy-looking case on my robotics workstation.
- xarball 13y agoI'd be curious to see for what price something of equal value goes for, versus something of equal spending.
- taopao 13y agoHow much would that case be worth to you?
- ScottWhigham 13y agoYes, there are dozens of companies who sell computers specifically designed around x where x = music recording, music production, video production, film. http://www.visiondaw.com/productcart/pc/index.asp http://www.visiondaw.com/productcart/pc/index.asp http://www.adkproaudio.com/ http://www.adkproaudio.com/
- velodrome 13y agoYou can get almost 3 base model Mac Pros for that price.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 13y agoOf course not. Why should I? I can build a PC to the same specs! Of course it won't run OS X well, it won't have the same exact specs, it will have severely worse construction with wires hanging here and there and huge fans, it won't be as silent, it will be bigger, components wont be selected, adjusted and tested to work together, and it might end up costing the same amount of money or near-ish after I add all the options (like the SSDs and thunderbold). And I'll have to support it myself, replacing parts if they fail, instead of just taking it to the Applestore for a fix. But that won't stop me saying it's overpriced.
- Osiris 13y agoand it might end up costing the same amount of money or near-ish after I add all the options I'd be interested to see someone do an analysis of what it would cost to buy off-the-shelf components that match in performance and see what the cost is. I would be very surprised if the cost of off-the-shelf build of similar specs were anywhere even close to $10k.
- c0nsumer 13y agoA coworker and I were discussing this earlier so I priced out a Dell workstation with fairly similar specs: same number of cores but across 2x CPUs, same RAM, same video card RAM, no 1TB of flash storage. The Dell ended up costing negligibly more, something like $50 or $60 above the Apple.
- Uchikoma 13y agoIn 2006 I wrote about how everyone claimed Apple was so expensive, and compared it to a similar specced Lenovo T60p, guess what? The Lenovo was either more expensive or same price, depending on the MacBook version.
- csmuk 13y agoT60p was far superior build to any MacBook ever made. My old T61 which is virtually identical had the living crap beaten out of it 10 hours a day for 5 years solid and it still works fine today. It had a new battery and a new fan and that was it. Well worth the investment.
- lxwang 13y agoBetteridge's law of headlines: "Any headline which ends in a question mark can be answered by the word no."
- jljljl 13y agoCan we just sticky this to the top of all posts with question marks so that we don't have to have it reposted every. single. time. ?
- raganwald 13y agoThe trouble is, the law cuts both ways: "You can go out and spec a similar machine to the new Mac pro, but should you?" So if we adopt the law wholesale, we can editorialize by reversing the premise we wish to imply.
- quarterto 13y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5742893 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5742893
- elyrly 13y agoGreat Quote
- lallysingh 13y agoFrom the article: "Going with these upgrade options, the Mac Pro with an AppleCare service plan comes to $5,148, about half the cost of the most-expensive computer you can configure. This is unquestionably an expensive workstation, though considered in the context of competing products like those from HP or Dell, you'll see that similarly specced PC workstations are in the same ballpark (though these dual-socket workstations make true apples-to-Apple comparisons more difficult, and it's harder to quantify the value of real drive bays and PCI Express slots)." Whenever I've looked at non-cheap machines, independent of OS (I'm often flexible between macos and linux), the difference between an apple machine and something from another major vendor, for as closely-comparable machines I can find, is often a fairly small percentage. And considering the unique features of the devices -- usually better (exterior) case design, MacOS, etc., it's pretty reasonable.
- bryanlarsen 13y agoIf Apple is being true to form, the Mac Pro will be competitively priced, with two important caveats: 1. No option to use non-premium components. The two most obvious examples are the fact that you can't replace the Xeon with an i7 or the FirePro with a Radeon. 2. The prices will change slowly or not at all over time. $400 for a RAM upgrade might be reasonable now, but it won't be in a years time.
- kps 13y agoWhen I bought my 2008 Mac Pro, it was actually slightly cheaper than any equivalent name-brand PC workstation. I still don't understand the target market for the new model, though. Who wants multiple graphics cards but limited RAM and no disks?
- beachstartup 13y agowe spend $10k on individual servers all the time, among other things. to some people, and most businesses, $10k is not a lot of money. especially for a capital good that can be purchased or leased without spending $10k of cash. for example, i can imagine upgrading an editing bay or scientific workstation for $10k is kind of a no-brainer. to put this into terms that people on HN can understand: $10k buys you about 6 months of cc2.8xlarge on ec2 on-demand.
- astrodust 13y agoEspecially when you bill out the editing bay at $100/hr or more.
- tbarbugli 13y agonever
- patrickg_zill 13y agoThe FirePro line is the most expensive of the graphics cards. Compare the actual specs to desktop cards like the Radeon R9 series (which top out at $500 or $600 each retail) and you will see that it is far more likely that Apple is taking those chips and using them.
- astrodust 13y agoThe benchmarks for these are tricky. "Pro" cards have more floating point "double" performance, but most games only use the less accurate but faster "single" mode.
- hobbe80 13y agoIf you buy this to play games (or rather - if game performance is where your computer needs max out), you're probably a person with enough money to not sweat a $10k computer purchase more than I mull over a fancy meal with the missus. Now, if you're a 3D artist (maybe game designer?) this looks really nice (caveat: not a 3D artist). So, designing fancy games - Mac Pro. Playing said fancy games - anything from iPhone to home-built gaming rig will be more worth it.
- astrodust 13y agoWhile this system has a lot of GPU under the hood, many 3D applications aren't properly leveraging OpenCL or are using CUDA (Nvidia). I'm hoping that this pushes more towards OpenCL because of how much capability is there. Some rendering engines for popular apps like Maya support CUDA exclusively which is trouble. Still, nobody is building render farms out of Mac Pros. Right now this is geared towards video editors and audio engineers where more GPU translates directly into faster rendering and where you can never have enough 4K screens.
- lectrick 13y agoSteamOS on a Mac Pro: The most elitist of elite gaming machines
- headgasket 13y agoThat's about the price of the original mac512 with an external hard drive in todays dollars. 1984 (Mac 2795 + 10MB hd 1200) when factoring for inflation (2013) $9,009.01 http://www.davemanuel.com/inflation-calculator.php http://www.davemanuel.com/inflation-calculator.php?
- dignan 13y agoIt seems to me that everyone complaining about needing to deal with PC repairs has never had a business-class PC. The business and consumer support are completely different beasts. For business products, at least HP and Dell will send someone to you to fix it. These are competent techs who can do almost any repair/replacement on the spot. As far as I know Apple does not offer this level of support.
- bane 13y agoSince nobody here seems to have access to newegg here's the closest CPU: Xeon E5-2697 12-core 2.7 Ghz - $2749.99 Video: AMD FirePro S9000 6GB - $2199.99 ea. (close as I could get) - x2 $4,399.98 RAM: G.SKILL Ripjaws Z Series 64GB (8 x 8GB) 240-Pin DDR3 SDRAM DDR3 1600 (PC3 12800) Desktop Memory Model F3-12800CL10Q2-64GBZL - $599.99 SSD: SAMSUNG 840 EVO MZ-7TE1T0BW 2.5" 1TB SATA III MLC Internal Solid State Drive (SSD) $569.99 Motherboards that handle 64GB of RAM look to be generally under $400 Let's add $300 for case, PSU etc. and we're looking at ~$9000. So even if the individual upgrades are badly priced (64GB of RAM for $800!), the entire system is actually pretty fairly priced at the top configuration. The tight integration of the parts, and I'm guessing sourcing directly from the manufacturers rather than through 3rd party parts builders, probably cuts lots of the BOM out. And there's no way Apple won't make a profit on these ugly things.