3 ms·
Fines are not just to recompense the apparent victim of an action, they are intended to deter others from repeating the action. If the risk of getting caught is
by dspillett 13y ago
Fines are not just to recompense the apparent victim of an action, they are intended to deter others from repeating the action. If the risk of getting caught is small the fine needs to he high enough that ChanceOfGettingCaught*Punishment is far enough from zero that it figures in people's minds.
Unfortunately this only seems to apply to individuals: companies seem to get slap-on-the-wrist fines were individuals get send-you-to-the-poverty-line fines.
- tspiteri 13y agoI find the thought of having punishment inversely proportional to chance-of-getting-caught disturbing. Because if the risk of getting caught is very small (which is the very case the system would be addressing), the punishment would necessarily be disproportionately huge. I can never agree with a disproportionately huge punishment.
- belorn 13y agoThe word "fine" here is a mistranslation of the judgment. The court rewarded damages to be paid by the one sentenced. They did not issue any fines. Fines and damages are two different concepts, because one is about restoration (damages), while the other is about punishment and repentance. The first is about the victim, and the second is about the state. In this case, the court decided on $650,000 damages to be repaid to the rights alliance, and as punishment gave a suspended jail sentence and 160 hours of community service. > If the risk of getting caught is small the fine needs to he high enough that ChanceOfGettingCaught*Punishment is far enough from zero that it figures in people's minds. Thats not the point of either fines or damages. In a historical perspective, fines exist because other more inhumane punishments like beating, lashing and shaming were deemed inappropriate. In today's theory, (see http://www.criminology.su.se/polopoly_fs/1.74227.1328107386!/menu/standard/file/2011c_Josefine_Augustsson.pdf http://www.criminology.su.se/polopoly_fs/1.74227.1328107386!...), it's more about providing a standpoint in society about what is acceptable and what is not. It should also be mentioned that fines have a maximum of $600 per crime, or 150 days of a person's current income. Damages on the other hand are only about restoration, and is not allowed to be issued as punishment. It is illegal for the court to issue damages as a form of punishment.